ANALYSIS: BLACK FRIDAY AND CYBER MONDAY 2013, by DAVE RODGERSON

Date:

Share post:

[Image Source]



By Dave Rodgerson, Retail Industry Analyst and Consultant


Dave Rodgerson is a Retail industry expert with more than 25 years of executive experience working with leading Canadian Retailers in sales, marketing, operations and strategic planning roles.  He works closely with both clients and associations that share an interest in enhancing the consumer experience. Mr. Rodgerson’s expanded bio is provided at the end of this article. 


The 2013 shopping season is one of the shortest in history. With only 26 days between Thanksgiving and Christmas its 6 days shorter than last year. The end result is that retailers have almost a full week less to capture the business available to them through the holiday season. That has prompted a number of analysts to suggest that Thanksgiving 2013 would be a bigger shopping day that it has been in the past. The projection was accurate. According to IBM’s Digital Analytics Benchmark report, Thanksgiving saw a year-over-year increase of 19.7%. The “early” start to the shopping season may prompt retailers to allocate more focus on Thursday as the drop date for future promotions coming into the week. In Canada the day isn’t recognized as Thanksgiving or a holiday, but that didn’t prevent some retailers from tagging the day as “Grey Thursday”. Analysts at Accenture have suggested that in time, Thursday could become the largest sales day of the week. It makes sense when you think of the competitive nature of retailers and the challenge of capturing as much business as possible in a short window of time.

It was interesting to note that the largest change in Thanksgiving shopping came in the form of mobile transactions. In the past, shopping on mobile devices has traditionally stayed below 20% of total online volume. This year, 25.8% of online sales were generated by mobile devices.

 

[Image Source]



Black Friday did not disappoint the retailers either. The day achieved a record high in online sales growing 18.9% over the same day in 2012. In spite of this increase, the average basket size for Black Friday online orders only increased by 2.2% over 2012. What this does confirm is that the growth in online sales is not coming from increased individual spending, rather, it is the result of more people shopping online during this period. There are two things that contribute to this change in shopping behaviour; consumers are becoming more comfortable with the technology used to make purchases online as well as having a greater trust in the security of shopping online


There is an interesting split in the use of mobile devices during the Thursday to Monday shopping period. Smartphones drove 24.9% of all online traffic on Black Friday compared to tablets at 14.2%. In this sense they established themselves as the device of choice for browsing. They are much easier to use when shopping in stores as well, since most retailers do not offer Wi-Fi and most tablets are not equipped with 4G connectivity. Tablets were however the device used more frequently to complete purchases. Tablets drove 14.4% of online sales, smartphones accounted for only half that figure at 7.2%. Tablets also captured a larger basket than sales attributed to smartphones by almost 19%.

[Image Source]

Cyber Monday did not disappoint anyone. Online sales grew by 20.6 percent over 2012. The average order value was $128.77, down 1 percent year-over-year which again makes the point that more people are making the shift to shopping online.


Cyber Monday also generated a higher conversion rate on carted items. Shoppers actually purchased the items they added to their online shopping carts at a 12.6 higher rate on Cyber Monday than Black Friday.


Another trend that is becoming more apparent as online shopping increases through the holiday season is the influence of social media. Websites like Pinterest and Facebook are generating some of the traffic that contributes to online sales. While this percentage is small, (less than 1%) there is a growing trend of shoppers who are referred from these sites to online retailers. On average, holiday shoppers referred from Facebook spent 6 percent more per order than shoppers referred from Pinterest. Facebook average order value was $97.81 versus Pinterest average order value which was $92.40.  Facebook referrals converted sales at a rate 38 percent higher than Pinterest.

[Image Source

It will be interesting to watch how retailers connect with mobile shoppers in the future. On average, retailers sent 77 percent more push notifications during the five day holiday shopping period (the alert messages and popup notifications from apps installed on your mobile device), when compared to daily averages over the past two months.  The average daily installation of retail application on smartphones  also grew by 29 percent using the same comparison. This would seem to indicate no loss of appetite on the part of consumers for smartphone tools that enable their shopping.


“We continue to see a dramatic movement of the new digitally savvy consumer as Cyber Monday once again proved to be the star of this holiday shopping season,” said Jay Henderson, Strategy Director, IBM Smarter Commerce. “The mobile device has become the shopping companion of choice for consumers, driving record mobile sales with 55 percent growth over last year.”


About Dave Rodgerson 

 
Dave Rodgerson is a Retail industry expert with more than 25 years of executive experience working with leading Canadian Retailers in sales, marketing, operations and strategic planning roles.  He works closely with both clients and associations that share an interest in enhancing the consumer experience. 
 
His work has included consulting engagements with such firms as Tesco supermarkets in the UK, Canadian Tire Corporation, Target Department Stores, Imperial Tobacco, Walmart Canada and Sears Canada. He has played an active role with the National Retail Federation, the Retail Council of Canada and the Conseil Québécois du Commerce de Détail.
 
More recently, Dave has been speaking about emerging technologies and their impact on the customer experience. His audiences have included Unilever’s Global R&D team and Pepsi’s North American R&D group. He has been a featured speaker at Customer Engagement Technology World and the Canadian Gaming Association national conference. 


Dave has been a member of the faculty of Meritus University where he taught Marketing in their School of Business. In addition, he is on the Board at the University of Alberta School of Retail and works closely with the Ryerson School of Retail Business to support their program. In December 2013, he joined the Board of Directors at iSign Media Solutions.
 
Dave holds an MBA from Queen’s University in Kingston, Ontario where he focused on marketing strategies.

RELATED ARTICLES

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

RECENT articles

Birks names Sophie Nélisse brand ambassador as it launches new national campaign

Nélisse, who was born in Montreal and is known for her performances in Yellowjackets and Heated Rivalry, said the brand has been familiar to her since childhood.

Daily Synopsis: August 25, 2026

Loblaw backtracks on dropping country-of-origin produce labels, cosmetic tariffs threaten beauty, fashion and other sectors, Criterion opening video storefront in Toronto, shop-Canada app surges amid trade war, and other news.

Canada announces $27.6B in counter-tariffs on U.S. goods as retailers, restaurants and small businesses weigh impact

“Canada’s retail sector will shoulder a significant share of this burden, with so many essential consumer goods targeted."

Toronto’s Woodbine Mall and Fantasy Fair getting a roller rink this fall

The concept has opened more than 15 pop-ups in vacant retail spaces across the GTA and welcomed more than 250,000 skaters since 2021.

Evening Coffee Orders Nearly Triple in Canada as Restaurants Tap New Beverage Trend: Lavazza

Coffee is no longer just a morning ritual. Restaurants across Canada are finding a new use for their espresso machines well after the dinner rush.

Canadian SMEs remain optimistic but take more cautious approach to hiring and AI investment: Employment Hero

The survey suggests businesses are increasingly looking at AI as a tool for day-to-day operations rather than simply experimenting with the technology, with productivity and efficiency among the stated priorities.

Back-to-School lunch basket falls 2.8%, but relief may be temporary: report

Promotions are easing costs for families, while seasonal pressures and geopolitical risks could push some prices higher by December

Maureen Simon Foods launches Rolliis in 7-Eleven stores across Canada

The company said the products are being introduced across the convenience-store chain as it seeks to bring its lineup of Caribbean-inspired foods to a wider Canadian customer base.

Toronto Waterfront Looks to Events and Activation as District Builds Toward 2035

Waterfront BIA is mapping a new events and activation strategy as transit, development and commercial growth reshape Toronto’s waterfront through 2035.

Most Canadian small businesses unaware of new open banking law: Xero survey

Eighteen per cent of respondents said they currently share their online banking username and password with an accountant, bookkeeper, employee or software tool. Twenty-two per cent said they had done so at some point.

Arc’teryx Sees Potential for 200 Stores in North America as Expansion Accelerates

Arc’teryx sees potential for roughly 200 stores across North America as the Vancouver-founded brand expands retail, women’s and footwear.

Canadian Retailers Push Sustainability Deeper Into Operations as Business Case Evolves

Canadian retailers are integrating sustainability into stores, logistics, packaging, resale and supply chains as regulation and business economics evolve.

Daily Synopsis: August 24, 2026

Canadians still head to malls, Ilia Beauty grows out of Vancouver roots, Reformation opening at CF Toronto Eaton Centre Sept. 1, Toronto camera store closing after 25 years, and other news.

Casavogue Highlights Made-in-Italy Design from Calligaris

Casavogue showcases Calligaris, the Italian furniture brand known for refined extendable dining tables, elegant chairs and Made-in-Italy craftsmanship.

Westcliff acquires Kingsway Mall in Edmonton

On a 41.8-acre site, the 880,049-square-foot shopping centre features more than 160 stores and services.

Walmart+ Takes Bigger Role as Walmart Expands Canadian Digital Strategy

Walmart is expanding its Canadian digital strategy as Walmart+ membership, e-commerce, Marketplace and fulfillment investments gain importance.

Ottawa’s Tariff Retaliation Risks Raising Grocery Prices for Canadians

Sylvain Charlebois warns that Canadian counter-tariffs on U.S. food, ingredients and agricultural inputs could raise grocery prices and increase costs across the food supply chain.

AI’s Growth Reveals a Hidden $381.3 Million Problem for Retail Brands: Outdated and Unmanaged Enterprise Content

88% of retail executives say high-quality, well-maintained digital content will be more important to their business success over the next two years than it has been in the past

AI Is Shaping Back-to-School Shopping for Canadian Consumers: Accenture

AI is influencing how Canadians plan back-to-school purchases, with parents using AI tools to compare prices, build shopping lists and find products.

Canadian, U.S. and Mexican franchise groups sign trilateral agreement

The agreement is intended to help franchise businesses better understand and enter each other's markets, including through greater information sharing on regulations, intellectual property, costs, supply chains, consumers and market-entry strategies.