How Sears Canada Could Have Been Saved: Expert

Date:

Share post:

A veteran Canadian retail consultant says Sears Canada didn’t have to close down its operations and could have stayed alive if the company adopted a unique and innovative strategy.

Mark Healy, a Toronto-based consultant in investment banking, real estate and retail, was a Canadian Tire franchise owner for 20 years and says Sears could have taken a look at creating a system of franchise ownership similar to Canadian Tire.

“About a year and a half ago, I tried to get ahold of Sears,” says Healy. “They were changing CEOs every two years.”

“I was thinking of my Canadian Tire days and how the system works but I’m thinking a lot of the stores at Sears were catalogue stores or actually dealer stores. So my thinking was with regards to Sears to save it you franchise the stores just like the Canadian Tire model.”

Sears Canada closed all its remaining stores in the country in mid-January. At one point in time, the company, which began operations in Canada in 1953, had 190 stores and well over 15,000 employees.

The controversial closure continues to make headline news across the country as former employees battle in court over a pension shortfall.

“I would have franchised it,” says Healy. “A lot of the stores they were hemorrhaging and bleeding with they could have leased them out or you redevelop. You repurpose that land. You build them into condos. You bring the customers to the mall – the vacant mall.”

“The most important thing is they didn’t have an ecommerce platform. They didn’t have anybody that could handle that. Guess what. Amazon’s going out and building brick and mortar stores. Cut a deal with Amazon and get them to handle your back end. Let them take the ecommerce. Let them do the deliveries. Let them do everything. I think there could have been an opportunity there with Amazon. It’s too late now obviously but I honestly believe that Sears didn’t really want to survive.”

PHOTO: CHAIN STORE AGE

Healy says he tried numerous times to present his plan to Sears.

“I couldn’t get through to anybody,” he says. “Couldn’t get through to Fort Knox.”

His idea of the franchise model would have meant that dealers would have had equity in the store.

“And usually like the Canadian Tire model you have some skin in the game. You care if the lights go off at 9:15 that they’re not burning all night. You watch your wages. You run a better store. You have profit sharing,” says Healy.

“What they do (Canadian Tire) is they own the land and the building. They charge the dealers a percentage of sales for rent. They take a mark up on the inventory but the dealers finance in the inventory and the assets. And they own it. And they make it work.”

“You need to have a dealer in there. A GM (general manager) is not going to care. At the end of the day, he’s going to do his best but there’s only so much he can do. But if you have skin in the game you make it work. You’re rotating your inventory. You’re worried about your discontinueds. You’re a buyer on the premises. You know what’s moving.”

Healy says he would have also renamed Sears.

“It’s an old name. It’s an American name. I would have rebranded it,” says Healy. “They brought in all these specialists spending money on fashion, accessories. Just get down to the retail street. Give the customers what they want. Service the heck out of them. I would have changed the name – made it more a Canadian name.”

2 COMMENTS

  1. Why doesn’t Sears open again, but go completely online? No need for a store and associated costs.
    I miss Sears products and would love to see them online. Seems like a win win situation?

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More From Retail Insider

Pret A Manger to Expand Across Canada with Standalone Locations Following 2-Year A&W Trial

The popular UK-based foodservice business will begin a national rollout of its standalone concept after testing the market in A&W locations as well as a standalone storefront in Toronto.

Why are Grocery Bills so High in Canada? A New Study Looks at the Science Behind Food Price Reporting [Op-Ed]

University researchers reviewed factors impacting food costs in Canada, discussing what's causing rising prices and what can be done about it.

German Outdoor Retailer Wellensteyn to Enter Canada and Open Stores with 5 Year Expansion Plan [Interviews]

The first Canadian location will open this summer, as the brand known for its sturdy outerwear strategizes a national store expansion.

Declining Sales and Footfall Plague Canadian Retailers [J.C. Williams Group StatCan Analysis]

The consultancy analyses March data, noting a slowdown in some retail categories and a rise in food prices that led to recent boycotts.

US-Based Second-Hand Electronics Retailer ‘PayMore’ to Enter Canada with Rapid Store Expansion [Interview]

The retailer obtains and repurposes old electronics to recirculate them into the marketplace, and is expanding into Canada with stores that aim to gain market share rapidly.

Canada’s Competition Bureau Launches Investigation into Loblaws and Sobeys [Op-Ed]

Sylvain Charlebois says that grocers must recognize that today's market is different, with consumers being less tolerant of practices limiting access to affordable food.

Anatomy of a Leader: Sarah Segal, CEO of DAVIDsTEA

Segal discusses her career and how she got to to where she is today, as well as a family history that includes founding a toy store in Montreal and big banners such as Le Chateau.

Apple Launches Tap to Pay on iPhone in Canada, Revolutionizing Contactless Payments for Businesses

Apple says it will allow businesses to seamlessly and securely accept payments using an iPhone and app, adding competition to the crowded payments space.

Half a Billion Dollar Downtown Ottawa Revitalization Announced to Bring Vibrancy to the Core [Feature/Interviews]

The Ottawa Board of Trade and the Canadian Urban Institute launched the initiative that will create new retail opportunities with the addition of 40,000 new residents and 50,000 jobs over 10 years, creating a more vibrant core that will be a destination.

Bayview Village to Overhaul Property with Marble Flooring and Luxe Interior, New Retailers and Restaurants Being Added [Exclusive Renderings/Interviews]

The Toronto shopping centre at Bayview and Sheppard is being transformed into something unrecognizable, creating a 'European-style' centre unlike competitors in the region.

Food Prices Dropping in Canada, Mainstream Media Fails to Report [Op-Ed]

Sylvain Charlebois says that food prices are declining according to StatCan data, but that media and the public have been focusing elsewhere.

Innovative App ‘Too Good To Go’ Rescues 4.2 Million Meals in Canada Since 2022, Plans for Expansion [Interview]

The innovative platform is looking to expand by adding more retailers, after launching two years ago by offering consumers excess end-of-day edible goods from a wide range of businesses.

New Hockey Legends Training Facility in Markham ON Elevates Player Skills with Cutting-Edge Technology [Interview]

The unique indoor training concept allows players to practice including improving shooting and stickhandling skills.

Arc’teryx Opens First ‘Alpha’ Store Concept on Bloor Street in Toronto [Photos]

The largest Arc'teryx store also focuses heavily on product care, and is located on the Mink Mile in the Holt Renfrew Centre.

Waterworks Food Hall to Open in Downtown Toronto Next Month, Showcasing 20 Gourmet Vendors in Historic Location [Interview/Photos]

The highly anticipated food hall on Richmond Street will span 55,000 square feet and will add more food and beverage competition in the downtown core with a range of hand-picked specialty vendors.

Bluenotes Launches ‘Unplug’ Activewear Shop-in-Shops in Stores Across Canada [Interview/Photos]

It's the first activewear line for the Canadian retailer, with dedicated shop-in-stores being part of a segment that is growing rapidly.

A Grocer Code of Conduct Could have Prevented Canada’s Bread Cartel [Op-Ed]

Sylvain Charlebois says that the grocer code aims to curb illegal activities that would make it tougher to orchestrate such schemes.

From Barbie to Thomas the Tank Engine: How Toy and Entertainment Brands are Adapting to Generation Alpha [Op-Ed]

A new more 'woke' generation means that toys and entertainment deemed acceptable in the past are no longer desirable to a new set of consumers.

Anatomy of a Leader: Dave Minnett, CEO of Edo Japan

Minnett discusses how his education and early years at Molson led him into different business avenues before landing at Edo in 2016, where he's implementing change.

Downtown Banff Welcomes New Mountain Warehouse Store Amidst National Expansion [Photos]

The UK-based outdoor retailer operates 43 stores in Canada, making it the second-largest market outside of the UK. The Banff Mountain Warehouse is next to a former Hudson's Bay that will see Arc'teryx open there next year.

RECENT RETAIL INSIDER VIDEOS

Advertisment

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

RECENT articles

Pret A Manger to Expand Across Canada with Standalone Locations Following 2-Year A&W Trial

The popular UK-based foodservice business will begin a national rollout of its standalone concept after testing the market in A&W locations as well as a standalone storefront in Toronto.

Why are Grocery Bills so High in Canada? A New Study Looks at the Science Behind Food Price Reporting [Op-Ed]

University researchers reviewed factors impacting food costs in Canada, discussing what's causing rising prices and what can be done about it.

German Outdoor Retailer Wellensteyn to Enter Canada and Open Stores with 5 Year Expansion Plan [Interviews]

The first Canadian location will open this summer, as the brand known for its sturdy outerwear strategizes a national store expansion.

Declining Sales and Footfall Plague Canadian Retailers [J.C. Williams Group StatCan Analysis]

The consultancy analyses March data, noting a slowdown in some retail categories and a rise in food prices that led to recent boycotts.

US-Based Second-Hand Electronics Retailer ‘PayMore’ to Enter Canada with Rapid Store Expansion [Interview]

The retailer obtains and repurposes old electronics to recirculate them into the marketplace, and is expanding into Canada with stores that aim to gain market share rapidly.

Canada’s Competition Bureau Launches Investigation into Loblaws and Sobeys [Op-Ed]

Sylvain Charlebois says that grocers must recognize that today's market is different, with consumers being less tolerant of practices limiting access to affordable food.

Anatomy of a Leader: Sarah Segal, CEO of DAVIDsTEA

Segal discusses her career and how she got to to where she is today, as well as a family history that includes founding a toy store in Montreal and big banners such as Le Chateau.

Apple Launches Tap to Pay on iPhone in Canada, Revolutionizing Contactless Payments for Businesses

Apple says it will allow businesses to seamlessly and securely accept payments using an iPhone and app, adding competition to the crowded payments space.

Half a Billion Dollar Downtown Ottawa Revitalization Announced to Bring Vibrancy to the Core [Feature/Interviews]

The Ottawa Board of Trade and the Canadian Urban Institute launched the initiative that will create new retail opportunities with the addition of 40,000 new residents and 50,000 jobs over 10 years, creating a more vibrant core that will be a destination.

Bayview Village to Overhaul Property with Marble Flooring and Luxe Interior, New Retailers and Restaurants Being Added [Exclusive Renderings/Interviews]

The Toronto shopping centre at Bayview and Sheppard is being transformed into something unrecognizable, creating a 'European-style' centre unlike competitors in the region.

Food Prices Dropping in Canada, Mainstream Media Fails to Report [Op-Ed]

Sylvain Charlebois says that food prices are declining according to StatCan data, but that media and the public have been focusing elsewhere.

Innovative App ‘Too Good To Go’ Rescues 4.2 Million Meals in Canada Since 2022, Plans for Expansion [Interview]

The innovative platform is looking to expand by adding more retailers, after launching two years ago by offering consumers excess end-of-day edible goods from a wide range of businesses.

New Hockey Legends Training Facility in Markham ON Elevates Player Skills with Cutting-Edge Technology [Interview]

The unique indoor training concept allows players to practice including improving shooting and stickhandling skills.

Arc’teryx Opens First ‘Alpha’ Store Concept on Bloor Street in Toronto [Photos]

The largest Arc'teryx store also focuses heavily on product care, and is located on the Mink Mile in the Holt Renfrew Centre.

Waterworks Food Hall to Open in Downtown Toronto Next Month, Showcasing 20 Gourmet Vendors in Historic Location [Interview/Photos]

The highly anticipated food hall on Richmond Street will span 55,000 square feet and will add more food and beverage competition in the downtown core with a range of hand-picked specialty vendors.

Bluenotes Launches ‘Unplug’ Activewear Shop-in-Shops in Stores Across Canada [Interview/Photos]

It's the first activewear line for the Canadian retailer, with dedicated shop-in-stores being part of a segment that is growing rapidly.

A Grocer Code of Conduct Could have Prevented Canada’s Bread Cartel [Op-Ed]

Sylvain Charlebois says that the grocer code aims to curb illegal activities that would make it tougher to orchestrate such schemes.

From Barbie to Thomas the Tank Engine: How Toy and Entertainment Brands are Adapting to Generation Alpha [Op-Ed]

A new more 'woke' generation means that toys and entertainment deemed acceptable in the past are no longer desirable to a new set of consumers.

Anatomy of a Leader: Dave Minnett, CEO of Edo Japan

Minnett discusses how his education and early years at Molson led him into different business avenues before landing at Edo in 2016, where he's implementing change.

Downtown Banff Welcomes New Mountain Warehouse Store Amidst National Expansion [Photos]

The UK-based outdoor retailer operates 43 stores in Canada, making it the second-largest market outside of the UK. The Banff Mountain Warehouse is next to a former Hudson's Bay that will see Arc'teryx open there next year.