Personal Information Collected by Retailers Must not Perpetuate Discrimination: Expert

Date:

Share post:

The recent unsettling reports that US retailer Anthropologie had been racially profiling its Black customers was alarming for several reasons, amongst which it came to light that this was common practice at its affiliated companies Free People and Urban Outfitters (all three are owned by the parent corporation URBN, and all three store banners are in Canada).

Aside from the systemic racism that was perpetuated through operational training and not corrected through sensitivity training, the issue of racial profiling on Black, Indigenous, and People of Colour in Canada and the United States arose at a time when public discourse on the topic is at all-time high. From a privacy perspective, this naturally raises the question as to whether personal information collected by retailers may inadvertently perpetuate systemic discrimination, even if technology and personal data are in and of themselves agnostic.

The concept of “profiling” in data privacy is used heavily in the EU General Data Protection Regulations, commonly referred to as the GDPR. It is defined in Article 4(4) as follows:

“Profiling” means any form of automated processing of personal data consisting of the use of personal data to evaluate certain personal aspects relating to a natural person, in particular to analyse or predict aspects concerning that natural person’s performance at work, economic situation, health, personal preferences, interests, reliability, behaviour, location or movements”.

The GDPR is considered the gold standard in global data privacy protection. Canadian data privacy laws, which has both Federal and Provincial versions that work harmoniously with one another, are deemed to have adequate safeguards similar to the EU’s. Retailers often have EU customers and wish to transfer data across borders to business partners and their own foreign offices, using the GDPR as a compliance mechanism. Even Canadian brands recognize the value of complying with GDPR as a harmonization tactic.

Applying GDPR as a Harmonizing Tactic

In the absence of comprehensive American federal consumer privacy legislation, the U.S. has a framework agreement, known as the Privacy Shield, to permit transfer of personal data between them and the EU. Americans brands also use GDPR as a compliance mechanism to strengthen their commitment to the Privacy Shield. This therefore means ensuring that profiling is performed correctly, because doing so through automation may negatively affect the rights of, and produces potentially detrimental legal effects, concerning natural persons. Under Article 22, all persons under the GDPR have the right to object to any decision based through automated decision-making that includes profiling.

Retailers often compile considerable personal information from their customers, including their home address for delivery, credit card, and other payment information, and purchase history, in order to perform directed marketing (usually in the form of e-mails and SMS texts). For instance, even though a customer disclosing their date of birth to a retailer to qualify for a “free gift” or additional benefit may seem benign, it is still personal information that the retailer must safeguard, the loss of which may result in legal liability if it were compromised.

Additionally, the transaction history a customer has with any brand is also personal data, as is any image of them captured on security cameras while shopping in the store. If a retailer also has a customer’s measurements or images, then that is also considered biometric information. Even metadata collected via web cookies or web beacons while online shopping contains location, traffic, and subscriber (customer) data that is classified as personal data under the GDPR, which retailers may aggregate and use to provide services and create marketing.

With such a rich cluster of information on their customers, retailers are now able to potentially evaluate natural persons and make decisions on their past history with the brand, and make decisions on those customers. This is not necessarily a bad thing if a retailer wishes to better understand their customer and grow their business, particularly if they specialize in a particular niche clientele. Responsible collection of personal information can only help a brand connect with their customers and tailor their goods or services to meet those expectations.

For instance, if a customer spends a certain amount of money per year with a brand, they are likely to be considered the most loyal or the top spenders. However, in combining that data with other identifiers, such as the customer’s address, race or ethnicity, measurements, and credit history, is it possible to profile other customers in the same database to determine and predict behaviour? While profiling as a practice is not in and of itself racist, technology may inadvertently include and exclude key customer demographics. This may mean that automated decision-making through profiling might prevent extending offers and invitations, such as to private sales, credit card offers, or other benefits, to potential customer groups who may not fit the targeted demographic, based on aggregated group identifiers, which may be a form of discrimination. Doing so may imply that a brand is not inclusive, a blight that cannot be explained away by a social media consultant or publicist posting a black square and an apology on social media.

Profiling can be Used for Good

There are ways to use profiling for good, as long as it is performed in a way that is compliant with privacy laws, and in an information-agnostic way that does not inadvertently prevent customers from participating on the basis of immutable characteristics such as race. The author of the article Utilizing PIAs to Limit Institutional Discrimination and Bias recommends that having a privacy officer or legal counsel complete a privacy impact assessment on electronic systems may be a way to uncover unconscious bias that technology does not and cannot recognize.

Similarly, conducting a privacy impact assessment on a project during the design phase, such as marketing surveys or advertising campaigns, is an additional safeguard that can not only help a brand comply with the GDPR and other binding regulations, but also to ensure that unconscious biases are examined and eliminated to promote inclusivity.

In an era when retailers are collecting more and more data from customers to effect service delivery, it is incumbent on retailers to not only safeguard their personal information, but to use that data for good. Privacy and protection of personal information is not just due diligence, but also one of the most effective ways to develop customer brand loyalty, diversify a retailer’s clientele, and commit to the fight for racial equality and equal opportunity. After all, unconscious biases are very last season.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More From The Author

The New Grocery Code of Conduct Should Benefit Both Canadians and the Food Industry [Op-Ed]

An industry expert provides an overview of what the new code should improve and supply chain management practices as consumers grapple with rapid food inflation.

Columbus Café Expands Rapidly in Canada, Opening 10th Location in Montreal and Announcing First Toronto Location [Interview]

The Parisian chain is looking to grow its presence in Canada significantly with a goal for a significant number of locations, according to its broker.

Swarovski Opens Unique One-of-a-Kind Canadian Concept Store on Bloor Street in Toronto [Photos]

Toronto is one of only a handful of cities globally to feature Swarovski’s new Instant Wonder concept store design. 

Healthy Planet Expands in Southern Ontario with 4 New Locations and Innovative Healthy Planet Kitchen [Interview]

One of Canada's fastest growing health and wellness retail chains is growing its brick-and-mortar presence while launching a new concept, says its GM.

Canadian Restaurants Facing Impending Bankruptcies as CEBA Loan Repayment Deadline Looms [Survey]

Research is showing an increase in bankruptcies with a loan repayment deadline at the end of the year potentially throwing the industry into chaos.

Louis Vuitton Opens Canada’s 2nd Men’s Ready-to-Wear Concession at Holt Renfrew Ogilvy in Montreal [Photos]

The luxury superbrand is growing its ready-to-wear presence in Canada in the country’s second-largest city, which will see even more clothing when a flagship Vuitton opens at Royalmount next year.

The Body Shop North America Appoints New General Manager to Expand Business: Interview with Jordan Searle

Searle discusses plans to upgrade stores with The Body Shop's new Workshop concept as the brand continues to see consumer growth amid competition.

Canadian Consumers will Abandon Checkouts if Preferred Payment Methods Unavailable [Study/Interview]

A new report examines consumer behaviour in Canada, indicating that retailers need to invest in tech to gain shopper loyalty.

Rack Attack Continues Expansion in Canada, Adding Three New Stores and Acquiring Calgary Locations [Interview]

The retailer of car racks, bike racks, rooftop tents, overlanding, and other outdoor gear is growing its operations in Canada with plans for more locations amid consumer demand.

Pilgrim CEO Robert Hayes Discusses the Jeweller’s Expansion Plans in Canada: Video Interview

The discussion includes how Hayes brought the brand into the market, what makes it so popular, wholesale expansion, and what's in store for new locations in Canada including one at CF Toronto Eaton Centre opening in late June.

Fitness Concept elleTO Growing Business with Female-Focus [Interview]

Founder Michelle Epstein discusses the rebrand and location moves which are proving successful for the 12-year old women's gym.

Montreal-Based Gourmet Salad Brand Mandy’s Sets Ambitious Expansion Plans, Eyeing National and International Growth [Interview]

The popular salad restaurant chain is looking at opening a substantial number of locations, given success after a recent expansion.

Sheridan Nurseries Marks 110 Years with Grand Opening of Innovative Garden Centre Concept in Aurora [Interviews]

The Ontario-based garden retailer has a unique history of land acquisition while retailing a variety of plants and items for the home.

Jeweller Alan Anderson Discusses His Line, Atelier and Future Plans: Video Interview

Craig interviews Toronto-based jeweller Alan Anderson, who discuses how he got started in the jewellery industry, his new atelier on Jarvis Street, and future plans which will include the launch of a handbag line. They also discuss the recent Royal Coronation and jewellery seen on various attendees. 

Canadians Are Now Buying Less Food. Now What for Grocery Retailers? [Op-Ed]

Sylvain Charlebois says a variety of factors could be at play to explain an interesting phenomenon among Canadian consumers.

Fashion Brand ‘Kotn’ Continues Canadian Retail Expansion with 5th Store in Toronto’s Leslieville [Interview]

The retailer's co-founder discusses Kotn's brand and retail strategy, including plans for future expansion.

Innovative Beauty Hall and Wellness Retail Concept to Open at Royalmount in Montreal [Interview/Rendering]

The opening of the 36,000 square foot space is set to for August 2024 as part of a highly anticipated new retail centre with numerous luxury tenants.

How AI is Changing the Retail Landscape in Canada and Beyond

From chatbots to robotics, change is rapid as AI takes hold and retailers look to adopt and integrate new technologies.

HBC to Expand Zellers Brand Across Canada in Larger Footprints After Spring Pop-Up Store Launch [Interviews]

The Hudson’s Bay Company is ramping up its investment in Zellers while also freeing up liquidity to grow its operating businesses with other banners.

Analyzing Canada’s 2023 Retail Sales: Insights into Category Growth and Challenges Ahead [J.C. Williams Group Analysis]

The consultancy analyses the latest StatCan numbers, showing some interesting trends over the year before.

RECENT RETAIL INSIDER VIDEOS

Advertisment

Subscribe to the Newsletter

RECENT articles

The New Grocery Code of Conduct Should Benefit Both Canadians and the Food Industry [Op-Ed]

An industry expert provides an overview of what the new code should improve and supply chain management practices as consumers grapple with rapid food inflation.

Columbus Café Expands Rapidly in Canada, Opening 10th Location in Montreal and Announcing First Toronto Location [Interview]

The Parisian chain is looking to grow its presence in Canada significantly with a goal for a significant number of locations, according to its broker.

Swarovski Opens Unique One-of-a-Kind Canadian Concept Store on Bloor Street in Toronto [Photos]

Toronto is one of only a handful of cities globally to feature Swarovski’s new Instant Wonder concept store design. 

Healthy Planet Expands in Southern Ontario with 4 New Locations and Innovative Healthy Planet Kitchen [Interview]

One of Canada's fastest growing health and wellness retail chains is growing its brick-and-mortar presence while launching a new concept, says its GM.

Canadian Restaurants Facing Impending Bankruptcies as CEBA Loan Repayment Deadline Looms [Survey]

Research is showing an increase in bankruptcies with a loan repayment deadline at the end of the year potentially throwing the industry into chaos.

Louis Vuitton Opens Canada’s 2nd Men’s Ready-to-Wear Concession at Holt Renfrew Ogilvy in Montreal [Photos]

The luxury superbrand is growing its ready-to-wear presence in Canada in the country’s second-largest city, which will see even more clothing when a flagship Vuitton opens at Royalmount next year.

The Body Shop North America Appoints New General Manager to Expand Business: Interview with Jordan Searle

Searle discusses plans to upgrade stores with The Body Shop's new Workshop concept as the brand continues to see consumer growth amid competition.

Canadian Consumers will Abandon Checkouts if Preferred Payment Methods Unavailable [Study/Interview]

A new report examines consumer behaviour in Canada, indicating that retailers need to invest in tech to gain shopper loyalty.

Rack Attack Continues Expansion in Canada, Adding Three New Stores and Acquiring Calgary Locations [Interview]

The retailer of car racks, bike racks, rooftop tents, overlanding, and other outdoor gear is growing its operations in Canada with plans for more locations amid consumer demand.

Pilgrim CEO Robert Hayes Discusses the Jeweller’s Expansion Plans in Canada: Video Interview

The discussion includes how Hayes brought the brand into the market, what makes it so popular, wholesale expansion, and what's in store for new locations in Canada including one at CF Toronto Eaton Centre opening in late June.

Fitness Concept elleTO Growing Business with Female-Focus [Interview]

Founder Michelle Epstein discusses the rebrand and location moves which are proving successful for the 12-year old women's gym.

Montreal-Based Gourmet Salad Brand Mandy’s Sets Ambitious Expansion Plans, Eyeing National and International Growth [Interview]

The popular salad restaurant chain is looking at opening a substantial number of locations, given success after a recent expansion.

Sheridan Nurseries Marks 110 Years with Grand Opening of Innovative Garden Centre Concept in Aurora [Interviews]

The Ontario-based garden retailer has a unique history of land acquisition while retailing a variety of plants and items for the home.

Jeweller Alan Anderson Discusses His Line, Atelier and Future Plans: Video Interview

Craig interviews Toronto-based jeweller Alan Anderson, who discuses how he got started in the jewellery industry, his new atelier on Jarvis Street, and future plans which will include the launch of a handbag line. They also discuss the recent Royal Coronation and jewellery seen on various attendees. 

Canadians Are Now Buying Less Food. Now What for Grocery Retailers? [Op-Ed]

Sylvain Charlebois says a variety of factors could be at play to explain an interesting phenomenon among Canadian consumers.

Fashion Brand ‘Kotn’ Continues Canadian Retail Expansion with 5th Store in Toronto’s Leslieville [Interview]

The retailer's co-founder discusses Kotn's brand and retail strategy, including plans for future expansion.

Innovative Beauty Hall and Wellness Retail Concept to Open at Royalmount in Montreal [Interview/Rendering]

The opening of the 36,000 square foot space is set to for August 2024 as part of a highly anticipated new retail centre with numerous luxury tenants.

How AI is Changing the Retail Landscape in Canada and Beyond

From chatbots to robotics, change is rapid as AI takes hold and retailers look to adopt and integrate new technologies.

HBC to Expand Zellers Brand Across Canada in Larger Footprints After Spring Pop-Up Store Launch [Interviews]

The Hudson’s Bay Company is ramping up its investment in Zellers while also freeing up liquidity to grow its operating businesses with other banners.

Analyzing Canada’s 2023 Retail Sales: Insights into Category Growth and Challenges Ahead [J.C. Williams Group Analysis]

The consultancy analyses the latest StatCan numbers, showing some interesting trends over the year before.