Pusateri’s Fine Foods Reopens Fire-Devastated Flagship (and it’s Better than Ever)

Date:

Share post:

Upscale Toronto-based grocery retailer Pusateri’s Fine Foods reopened its flagship store last Friday, located at 1539 Avenue Road in Toronto. The 15,000 square foot store, designed by Montreal-based GH+A, brings Pusateri’s original store up-to-par with its new locations across the Greater Toronto Region.

The reopening follows a devastating fire that closed the store in August of last year. The team at Pusateri’s worked hard over the past several months to bring the store back to life, as the company has been eager to reopen its doors to its loyal clientele. 

An excited crowd of over 100 people stood outside the store the morning of the opening. The first 500 guests in line were treated to a Pusateri gift bag, containing Pusateri branded t-shirts, and an assortment of grocery offerings including coconut water, yogurt-covered pretzels, and biscotti. 

The Pusateri family arrived for the 9am ribbon cutting, alongside a trendy and stylish Mr. and Mrs. Claus to celebrate the upcoming holiday season. As the gates open, a long line of shoppers gathered inside the store to explore the new changes to the space.

In the store, customers are greeted by a large two-storey atrium, featuring an impressive lighting addition that rises above Pusateri’s Cafe. Found here are artisanal baked goods including croissants, danishes, cakes, and macarons. A variety of different coffee and espresso drinks are available to order – with the same friendly and familiar service that was here before the renovation.

The finishings at Pusateri’s are top notch. White and grey patterned marble floors line the entire store, with rich wood fixtures and detailing giving the grocery store a sophisticated feel.

Just to the right of the cafe area lies the Pasticceria, where a selection of cakes and pies can be found. Fresh loaves and baguettes of bread are baked right in front of customers in Pusateri’s Panifico section.

The renovated location improves on what Pusateri’s flagship location had before. A new booth at Pusateri’s is a live cooking area, called the Rosticceria, featuring gourmet fresh foods and rotisserie items available for purchase. This cooking area can be found inside their new food hall at Saks Fifth Avenue on Queen Street West.

This area also has an elevated array of handmade sushi offerings, hand-rolled by expert sushi chefs.

The second floor offers a view over the grab-and-go food area. On this level, customers will find Christmas merchandise (seasonal) available for purchase, as well as customer washrooms. 

This floor will also house a Pusateri branded full-service Italian restaurant, set to open early next year, but was not ready in time for opening day.

Pusateri’s Fine Foods is also continuing its relationship with Toronto-based Greenhouse Juice Co. The juice company has opened a shop-in-shop featuring all varieties of their cold pressed juices. Greenhouse representatives kicked off the launch with complimentary samples of their ‘East of Eden’ and ‘Wake Up’ juices to an enthusiastic crowd. 

Pusateri’s Avenue Road has added over 100 new products to their grocery offerings. An increased selection of local and international cheeses, bolstered deli meat offerings, and an expanded selection of breads were made possible by the added space from the renovation. The product offering aligns with their offerings at their other locations, focusing on a selection of foods not typically found at big box grocery retailers.

This location was Pusateri’s first store, and has been operating for nearly 30 years. The company has since expanded to include grocery locations in Toronto’s affluent Yorkville area, Toronto’s Bayview Village, and at Oakville’s RioCan Oakville Place. Pusateri’s also operates two food halls within Saks Fifth Avenue at Toronto’s CF Sherway Gardens and at CF Toronto Eaton Centre-Queen Street.

1 COMMENT

  1. With all the effort to get the interior right – you would think they’d pay a bit more attention to the exterior. The architecture and public realm here are in serious need of some TLC.

Comments are closed.

RELATED ARTICLES

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

RECENT articles

Joseph Tassoni Calls ‘Natural Authority’ His Best Show Yet as Canadian Brand Builds

Canadian designer Joseph Tassoni discusses his Natural Authority runway show in Toronto, his Oakville showroom and his strategy for controlled brand growth.

Retail Insider’s Canadian Retail Monitor — September 2026: Consumer Spending Becomes Selective

Canadian retail is experiencing widening demand gaps across categories, regions and price points as value considerations move deeper into retailer strategy.

Toronto Waterfront Retail Market Evolves as Eastern District Builds Out

Toronto’s waterfront retail market is evolving as new businesses, experiential concepts, transit investment and major eastern waterfront development create new commercial opportunities.

Lunaro Hospitality opens first restaurant with chef Justin Friedlich in Toronto

Shay Ristorante is named after Friedlich’s daughter and is described as a personal expression of his heritage and story, with a focus on creating a dining experience centred on family and Italian culinary traditions.

Canadian Grocery Supply Chains Face Rising Costs and Disruption Risks: Capgemini

Canadian grocers face tariff pressures, raw-material shortages and limited logistics alternatives as retailers diversify suppliers and strengthen supply-chain resilience.

Larry’s Catch opens a new warehouse in Vancouver as the brand makes inroads into Western Canada

The new facility will allow the brand to strengthen its delivery network, lower shipping costs and make its premium, wild-caught Canadian seafood more accessible to customers across British Columbia, Alberta and Saskatchewan.

OK Tire Launches National Video Series Spotlighting the People ‘Behind the Bay Doors’ (Video)

Documentary-style series puts community, entrepreneurship, and Canadian business at the forefront of national growth strategy.

Nightmare Bar Brings an Immersive Halloween Experience to Calgary

Calgary is getting a new Halloween destination filled with themed cocktails, interactive entertainment and unexpected scares.

Daily Synopsis: October 1, 2026

Tsawwassen Mills plans a large H Mart grocery and entertainment expansion while CF Chinook Centre adds Old Navy, SportChek, and Winners to boost retail offerings. In Quebec, La Cordee is shutting, and other news.

Why Canadian Retailers Are Losing Sales They’ve Already Won

Checkout friction can cost Canadian retailers thousands in sales. Konek can help merchants offer a simple and trusted payment experience.

La Cordée Closure Ends Six-Year Turnaround Attempt in Quebec Outdoor Market

Quebec outdoor retailer La Cordée is shutting down after 73 years, ending a six-year turnaround that included new ownership and store expansion. The retailer returned to creditor protection in July 2026 with more than $13 million in obligations.

Tsawwassen Mills Marks 10 Years with H Mart, TM Wander and New Entertainment Uses

Tsawwassen Mills marks 10 years as Central Walk expands the 1.2-million-square-foot centre with TM Wander, recreation and entertainment uses. A roughly 30,000-square-foot H Mart anchor is also targeted to open around Christmas 2027.

IKEA Canada celebrates 50 years in Canada

To mark the milestone, IKEA Canada is focused on affordability with 50% off one iconic IKEA product every weekend in October.

Canadian Retail Supply Chains Face Scrutiny as $63.3B in Imports Linked to Labour Risk

World Vision estimates $63.3 billion in Canadian imports were associated with documented child- or forced-labour risks in 2025, led by electronics and apparel, as Ottawa considers stronger border enforcement that could raise traceability demands for retailers.

Iconic outdoor lifestyle brand L.L.Bean reimagines its flagship store in Freeport, Maine

The reimagined Flagship store and campus, which is visited by many Canadian tourists each year,  immerses customers in the outdoor lifestyle inspired by Maine and surrounds them with the products designed to enjoy it.

CF Chinook Centre adding three major retailers

Old Navy, SportChek and Winners will be joining the tenant mix at Calgary's most popular shopping centre.

Honestly Good Chicken Fingers and Serruya Private Equity Announce Joint Venture to Fuel Global Growth

New partnership will support expansion of the Canadian-born restaurant brand across North America and international markets

Niagara Falls Tourism Faces Weather Challenges as Rain and Flooding Hit 2026 Summer Season

Niagara City Cruises says poor weather has reduced walk-up visits while committed travellers remain resilient, with operators looking to the fall shoulder season. Niagara City Cruises says poor weather has reduced walk-up visits while committed travellers remain resilient, with operators looking to the fall shoulder season.

Iconic Colombian coffee brand Juan Valdez expands to Canada

Juan Valdez is entering Canada for the first time as part of its North American expansion strategy, bringing the quality, origin and heritage of 100% Colombian premium coffee to Canadian consumers.

Daily Synopsis: September 30, 2026

Canada's Weston family moves to acquire UK chemist Boots for $9bn, The Brick sells Scarborough site, Ikea opens small-format London ON store, Fortinos opens Popcorn Kitchen in Brampton store, Pattison calls out grocery store violence in BC, and other news.