Pusateri’s Fine Foods Reopens Fire-Devastated Flagship (and it’s Better than Ever)

Date:

Share post:

Upscale Toronto-based grocery retailer Pusateri’s Fine Foods reopened its flagship store last Friday, located at 1539 Avenue Road in Toronto. The 15,000 square foot store, designed by Montreal-based GH+A, brings Pusateri’s original store up-to-par with its new locations across the Greater Toronto Region.

The reopening follows a devastating fire that closed the store in August of last year. The team at Pusateri’s worked hard over the past several months to bring the store back to life, as the company has been eager to reopen its doors to its loyal clientele. 

An excited crowd of over 100 people stood outside the store the morning of the opening. The first 500 guests in line were treated to a Pusateri gift bag, containing Pusateri branded t-shirts, and an assortment of grocery offerings including coconut water, yogurt-covered pretzels, and biscotti. 

The Pusateri family arrived for the 9am ribbon cutting, alongside a trendy and stylish Mr. and Mrs. Claus to celebrate the upcoming holiday season. As the gates open, a long line of shoppers gathered inside the store to explore the new changes to the space.

In the store, customers are greeted by a large two-storey atrium, featuring an impressive lighting addition that rises above Pusateri’s Cafe. Found here are artisanal baked goods including croissants, danishes, cakes, and macarons. A variety of different coffee and espresso drinks are available to order – with the same friendly and familiar service that was here before the renovation.

The finishings at Pusateri’s are top notch. White and grey patterned marble floors line the entire store, with rich wood fixtures and detailing giving the grocery store a sophisticated feel.

Just to the right of the cafe area lies the Pasticceria, where a selection of cakes and pies can be found. Fresh loaves and baguettes of bread are baked right in front of customers in Pusateri’s Panifico section.

The renovated location improves on what Pusateri’s flagship location had before. A new booth at Pusateri’s is a live cooking area, called the Rosticceria, featuring gourmet fresh foods and rotisserie items available for purchase. This cooking area can be found inside their new food hall at Saks Fifth Avenue on Queen Street West.

This area also has an elevated array of handmade sushi offerings, hand-rolled by expert sushi chefs.

The second floor offers a view over the grab-and-go food area. On this level, customers will find Christmas merchandise (seasonal) available for purchase, as well as customer washrooms. 

This floor will also house a Pusateri branded full-service Italian restaurant, set to open early next year, but was not ready in time for opening day.

Pusateri’s Fine Foods is also continuing its relationship with Toronto-based Greenhouse Juice Co. The juice company has opened a shop-in-shop featuring all varieties of their cold pressed juices. Greenhouse representatives kicked off the launch with complimentary samples of their ‘East of Eden’ and ‘Wake Up’ juices to an enthusiastic crowd. 

Pusateri’s Avenue Road has added over 100 new products to their grocery offerings. An increased selection of local and international cheeses, bolstered deli meat offerings, and an expanded selection of breads were made possible by the added space from the renovation. The product offering aligns with their offerings at their other locations, focusing on a selection of foods not typically found at big box grocery retailers.

This location was Pusateri’s first store, and has been operating for nearly 30 years. The company has since expanded to include grocery locations in Toronto’s affluent Yorkville area, Toronto’s Bayview Village, and at Oakville’s RioCan Oakville Place. Pusateri’s also operates two food halls within Saks Fifth Avenue at Toronto’s CF Sherway Gardens and at CF Toronto Eaton Centre-Queen Street.

1 COMMENT

  1. With all the effort to get the interior right – you would think they’d pay a bit more attention to the exterior. The architecture and public realm here are in serious need of some TLC.

Comments are closed.

RELATED ARTICLES

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

RECENT articles

Groupe Dynamite Shifts Growth to Higher-Productivity Stores as Garage Expands Globally

Groupe Dynamite is reshaping Garage around an older customer, higher-productivity stores and global expansion while optimizing its Canadian network.

Empire Rejecting Tariff-Related Supplier Price Hikes as Trade Tensions Escalate

Empire says it is rejecting tariff-related supplier price increases for now, citing sourcing alternatives as Canada-U.S. trade tensions escalate.

From The Desk: Navigating Retail Expansion Amid Economic Pressure and Innovation

This week in Canadian retail: strategic expansion, shifting consumer behaviour, innovation, tariffs and operational discipline shape the market.

What Apple’s New iPhone Strategy Means for Canadian Retailers and Carriers

Apple’s iPhone Duo, higher Pro pricing and new launch calendar could reshape how Canadian retailers, carriers and consumers buy and sell Apple hardware.

Fraud Is Costing Canadian Merchants More Than They May Realize

The financial impact of fraud extends well beyond a lost transaction. Konek can help Canadian retailers build trust into the payment experience from the start.

Nearly 400 consumer insolvencies filed every day in Canada: Harris & Partners

New federal figures show consumer insolvencies increased by 2.2%, while separate research found more than one-third of respondents had skipped essentials because of financial pressure.

Canadian Retailers Rethink Pricing Strategies as U.S. Tariffs Hit Nearly 900 Product Categories

Continued trade tensions reinforce the importance of diversification across international markets.

Canadian Retail Properties Perform Well in the First Half of 2026: CBRE

Suburban fundamentals excelled in key retail formats, especially grocery-anchored centres, supported by population growth in select cities and consistent tenant demand, according to CBRE’s new survey

Ryde: Canada launches sleep shot aimed at Canadians struggling to fall asleep

Ryde: cited data showing that 20 per cent of Canadian adults report having trouble going to sleep or staying asleep most or all of the time as part of the rationale for introducing the product.

Winnipeg-based Activate to open first Australian location in Melbourne in early 2027

Activate Melbourne (Highpoint) will be located next to HOYTS Cinema in Maribyrnong, Victoria, marking the company's entry into the Australian market and the first of several planned openings across the country.

INDOCHINO launches Fall/Winter 2026 campaign focused on made-to-measure tailoring

Called Hold the Room, the campaign follows four friends over a weekend, using three settings — an afternoon arrival, an evening lounge and a formal dinner — to showcase the company's tailoring and fabrics.

Daily Synopsis: Sep 10, 2026

Dynamite reports numbers, Harry Rosen shutting Bloor flagship Sept 12 with relocation a week later, Empire reports quarter, consumers use AI ahead of holidays, Jersey Mike's targets 300 Canadian locations, and other news.

Protect Your Business Before Peak Shipping Season

Join Retail Insider and UPS Capital Canada on September 30 at Noon ET for a free webinar on peak-season shipping risks, and protecting profits.

Mercedes-Benz Refreshes Holt Renfrew Studio With Paul & Shark and New S-Class

Mercedes-Benz has refreshed its Holt Renfrew Studio in Toronto with a new Paul & Shark residency, the Canadian debut of the 2027 S-Class, and an immersive 140 Years of Innovation experience.

Trade war puts over 50,000 Canadian small businesses at risk: CFIB

The CFIB is calling for immediate tax relief for small businesses through a Small Business Corporate Tax Rate cut.

Nearly 4 in 10 Canadian Shoppers Are Using AI for Shopping: Salesforce

Salesforce says 39% of Canadian shoppers have used AI for shopping as product discovery, retail marketing and e-commerce begin to change.

Retail Accessibility Can Shape Sales and Customer Loyalty, Says Pamela Shainhouse

Pamela Shainhouse explains why accessibility in store design, staff training and ecommerce should be part of the customer experience for Canadian retailers.

Canada’s retail vacancy rate expected to remain elevated as market absorbs Hudson’s Bay closures

The Hudson's Bay closures had a significant impact on Canada's retail market in 2025, with vacancy at shopping malls rising from three per cent to eight per cent in the second quarter of that year.

How Canadian consumers can soften the blow of tariffs: NerdWallet

Canada’s latest batch of counter-tariffs affect a wide range of consumer goods, including beauty supplies, milk products, clothes, home appliances and exercise equipment. 

Groupe Dynamite sees revenue increase by 29.8% to $423.6 million in Q2

Net earnings for Q2 2026 increased by $49.5 million or 77.5% compared to Q2 2025.