Retailers Not Meeting Shoppers’ Expectations: Report

Date:

Share post:

By Mario Toneguzzi

Recent years have seen the retail narrative dominated by doom and gloom stories of customer spending on the decline and bricks and mortar locations shutting down.

But is the narrative true?

That’s the question posed by a new retail report by Salesforce and Publicis.SapientShopper-First Retailing: The New Rules of Retail from the Actions, Voices, and Eyes of Today’s Consumers.

“To enable and empower shopper success in a retail organization today, it’s absolutely critical to focus on these four pillars of consumer engagement: mobile, stores, intelligence, and connected experiences,” said Rob Garf, VP of Industry Strategy & Insights, Salesforce.


The report found three shopper-first mandates emerging that apply to virtually all retailers:

  • Make It Fresh. Create unique, non-commoditized products and compete at the speed of today’s shopper. 69 per cent of shoppers expect to see new merchandise when visiting a site or store;

  • Be Where I Am. Develop a frictionless experience that’s accessible to shoppers, wherever they need you to be. 87 per cent of shoppers begin their hunt in digital channels, up from 71 per cent last year; and

  • Give It Meaning. Strengthen the relationship with your customers through stronger values-driven connections, and recognize shoppers with personalization and loyalty initiatives. 64 per cent of shoppers agree or strongly agree that retailers don’t truly know them.




The report also found that: mobile accounts for 92 per cent of ecommerce order growth; 71 per cent of shoppers prefer to leave a store with a product in-hand; and personalization influences 38 per cent of all digital revenue.

“Shoppers reward brands that connect them with products and experiences in unique, agile packages,” said the report. “Our research – based on a global consumer survey, behavioral data and in-store mystery shopping visits – painted a clear picture of shopper’s continuous demand for new, innovative and customized products,” said the report. “Shoppers value freshness with their wallets, as 59 per cent of the top five per cent of products sold are new each month. This creates a sweeping product catalog churn of 32 per cent month over month. Speed and freshness play an important role in generating long-term brand loyalty and driving repeat purchases – two areas where brands have lost ground to both traditional competitors and marketplaces.


“Shoppers reward brands that anticipate and identify the precise moments when a need exists or interest is piqued in their shopping journey. Shoppers today are more connected than ever, seamlessly switching between channels and devices, all while expecting retailers to know them and make purchasing easy. Yet in our study, too many retailers didn’t meet shoppers’ expectations. For example, across the 70 physical store locations studied, the average mobile score was 1.74 out of 5, grading areas like in-store app experiences and tailored push notifications. Rather than leave omni-channel customers wondering where to go next, retailers must engage customers in context and on their terms.

“Shoppers reward brands that go beyond transactions and orders to be relevant and resonant. Today’s shoppers are relationship-driven, favouring brands that bring value and meaning to their lives. Retailers and brands must look for new ways to differentiate by appealing to customers’ emotions and forging connections based on shared beliefs. Our research found that shoppers reward brands that create lasting relationships over time — specifically through loyalty programs and one-to-one personalization efforts that extend across both digital and physical channels. Our survey found that 64 per cent of shoppers feel retailers “don’t truly know them,” highlighting the need for retailers to prove that they do.”

The report said retail sales in the first quarter of this year were up five per cent year-over-year with digital channels experiencing robust growth and ecommerce now accounting for 9.5 per cent of all retail sales. Consumer confidence also continues to rise.


Capture9.PNGCapture9.PNG

But the report also highlighted the fact that stores are closing “at an alarming rate” with more than 12,000 shuttered since the beginning of 2017 and Amazon is dominating, capturing 78 per cent of ecommerce growth in the U.S.

It said a new swarm of retail startups, direct-to-consumer brands, and new low-cost and experience-led competitors—combined with a backstage technology revolution in supply chain, robotics, automation, blockchain, and dark stores—are changing the way retailers compete in the digital age.

The full report can be found here: http://www2.publicisgroupe.net/shopper-first

Publicis.Sapient, the digital business transformation hub of Publicis Groupe, helps clients drive growth and efficiency and evolve the ways they work. It has more than 19,000 people and more than 100 offices around the globe.

Salesforce is a global CRM leader.


Mario Toneguzzi, based in Calgary has 37 years of experience as a daily newspaper writer, columnist and editor. He worked for 35 years at the Calgary Herald covering sports, crime, politics, health, city and breaking news, and business. For 12 years as a business writer, his main beats were commercial and residential real estate, retail, small business and general economic news. He nows works on his own as a freelance writer and consultant in communications and media relations/training. Email: mdtoneguzzi@gmail.com

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More From Retail Insider

RECENT RETAIL INSIDER VIDEOS

Advertisment

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

RECENT articles

Canadians driving surge in event-led travel as domestic bookings jump 15%: Flight Centre

Travellers are prioritizing meaningful experiences and exploring destinations closer to home.

Roots reports Q1 sales growth of 6.5% to $42.6 million

Net loss totaled ($10.1) million, as compared to ($7.9) million in Q1 2025.

SportChek opens Canada’s first-ever floating futsal pitch on Toronto Waterfront

SportChek Harbourfront FC brings together free public programming, interactive fan experiences, community play spaces and retail activations inspired by the growing excitement surrounding soccer in Canada.

Good Earth Coffeehouse opens at University of Alberta Hospital

Good Earth Coffeehouse is a network of authentic coffeehouses with over 50 locations across Canada.

Mondetta Expands Modern Ambition with Toronto, Calgary and Vancouver Stores

Mondetta is expanding its Modern Ambition menswear brand with new stores in Toronto, Calgary and Vancouver, while evaluating additional opportunities across Canada, the United States and Europe.

Federal government launches National Food Security Strategy

With the average transaction sitting at approximately $12 per person, restaurants provide an accessible source of nourishment for millions of Canadians.

Daily Synopsis: Jun 11, 2026

HBC Royal Charter welcomed at Winnipeg Ceremony, FreshCo opening 1st Vancouver Island store, Palliser Furniture acquired by Chinese company after 80 years, Bulgari opens in Vancouver, Dickey's Barbecue Pit opening at West Edmonton Mall, and other news.

What Happened to Canada’s Women’s Fashion Chains?

Many of Canada’s iconic women’s fashion chains have disappeared. Retail expert Antony Karabus explains how fast fashion, casualization and economic shifts changed the industry.

Chanel Opens Largest Store in Canada at Oakridge Park in Vancouver

Chanel has opened its largest store in Canada at Oakridge Park in Vancouver. The 13,000-square-foot location is the brand's first full-concept store in Canada and a key addition to the development's luxury retail lineup.

Dollarama sees more than 21% year-over-year sales growth in Q1, surpassing $1.8 billion

Net earnings increased by 10.4% to $302.3 million, resulting in a 13.3% increase in diluted net earnings per common share to $1.11, compared to $0.98.

Advertising influencing people to place a bet: CPA Canada

“You can’t hide from it; gambling ads are everywhere."

lululemon Returns to Oakridge Park with New Store Concept

lululemon has returned to Oakridge Park with one of its newest Canadian store concepts, featuring Pacific Northwest-inspired design, local programming and community engagement.

Pinterest sports trend report shows surge in women’s sports fashion and beauty trends

The La Roche Posay activation will run until July 22. 

German outerwear brand Wellensteyn targets 2nd Canadian store after strong Niagara debut

The success of the 2,350-square-foot store at Outlet Collection at Niagara demonstrates that Canada is a promising market for the international company and the goal is to open another in 2027.

Jersey Mike’s Subs to open 3rd downtown Toronto location

Redberry will open the third downtown Toronto Jersey Mike’s Subs at 160 Bloor St. E. on Wednesday June 17, with a fundraiser for Make-A-Wish Canada.

Honestly Good Chicken Fingers opens 4th location at Stock Yards Village in West Toronto 

With locations in Etobicoke, The Well and Vaughan Mills, the Stock Yards Village opening marks the fourth location in the Toronto area and sets the stage for broader growth across Canada and the United States.

CFIB urges Ottawa to protect supply chains in Canada Labour Code reforms

"Cancelled orders, delayed shipments, lost income: small businesses pay the price every time federally regulated supply chains grind to a halt."

Financial anxiety surges in Canada as costs climb

The number of those gripped by anxiety when thinking about personal finances has surged to 60%.

Daily Synopsis: Jun 10, 2026

FIFA store opens in downtown Vancouver without price tags, Calgary's European Bakery marks 20 years, Montreal Dunkin' operators bank on nostalgia, Bulgari unveils Oakridge Park store, vagrancy concerns on Spring Garden Road in Halifax, and other news.

Licensed establishments in Alberta now able to serve alcohol as early as 6 a.m.

This change gives licensees the option to open earlier to meet business needs and customer demand, including during occasions such as international sporting events and cultural celebrations.