Advertisement

The Bay vs. Holt’s: It’s Time for Label Wars…

Date:

Share post:

Canada’s two largest fashion retailers are in a sort of ‘label war’. The Hudson’s Bay Company (The Bay) and Holt Renfrew have been fighting to carry designers in a sparsly populated country where designer distribution is tightly controlled.  This ‘war’ will only intensify in anticipation of Nordstrom’s entry into Canada in late 2014, and furthermore as The Bay continues to upscale itself as a premiere fashion retailer. 

Ungaro gown in ‘The Room’ at Hudson’s Bay. Image used with permission by Rafael Escobar, owner of the blog Frock of Ages. [Image Source and Link]

Strolling through the second-floor of The Bay in Vancouver, for example, one finds numerous women’s designers available at both Holts and The Bay. To rattle off a few mutually-carried designers: Nina Ricci, Comme des Garcons, Balmain, Akris Punto, 3.1 Phillip Lim, Ralph Lauren Black Label, Nicholas Kirkwood shoes, Brian Atwood shoes, Vince, Diane von Furstenberg, Eileen Fisher, Elie Tahari, J-Brand Jeans, McQ by Alexander McQueen, Naked & Famous, Opening Ceremony, Theory and Z-Spoke Zac Posen. 

We’ll review menswear at both stores once The Bay’s sixth-floor men’s store is open in mid October. Again, expect some designer cross-over.

Shoe Shopping at The Bay in Vancouver (Image: thestylespy.com)

Our source at Vancouver’s Holt Renfrew tells us Holts has been scrambling to pick up some of the more upscale designers selling with some success at The Bay, including expensive designers Nina Ricci and Balmain, and shoe designers Brian Atwood and Nicholas Kirkwood. What’s interesting to note is The Bay’s pieces by these designers are generally more ‘out there’ and ‘unique’ compared to more subdued offerings by the same designers at Holt Renfrew.  This phenomenon is thanks a Bay buyer/creative director named Nicholas Mellamphy, who has carefully cultivated an avant garde, upscale image for The Bay’s luxury salon known as ‘The Room’. The Room is currently at Bay stores in Vancouver and Toronto, and will open tentatively next year in Montreal. 

The Bay has taken some women’s designers that Holt Renfrew has dropped, including DSquared2, Armani Collezioni, L’Wren Scott, Piazza Sempione, Moschino Couture and Thakoon. Our Holt Renfrew insider source notes that Armani Collezioni, DSquared2 and Piazza Sempione struggled at Holt Renfrew in Vancouver and were therefore dropped prior to being picked up by The Bay.

Readers in more remote parts of Canada may be surprised to hear that you can buy a $10,000 dress at The Bay. Readers can be assured that more remote Bay stores, some currently in awful shape, will be renovated via money raised from an initial public stock offering which is expected to happen between mid-October and the early New Year. 

Snakeskin Proenza Schouler bags, available at The Bay in Vancouver and Toronto. Price? If you have to ask, you can’t afford it… (ok fine, they’re just under $8,400 each)

We will keep you updated with various movements within Canada’s designer label availability, and we will start posting about where Canadians can find some premium designers. Be sure to follow us on Twitter and Facebook, as we sometimes provide insider retail information not posted on this website. 

Hudson’s Bay Company website: www.thebay.com

Holt Renfrew website: www.holtrenfrew.com

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More From Retail Insider

RECENT RETAIL INSIDER VIDEOS

Advertisment

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

RECENT articles

VIDEO: Franchise model helps Ontario bakery owner navigate economic uncertainty

Franchising can offer operational assistance such as human resources and technology support, along with brand recognition that helps create a stronger foundation for new business owners.

Jobs increase in May, unemployment rate edges down: Statistics Canada

Accommodation and food services sees employment growth while wholesale and retail trade experience decrease.

Veronica Beard Opens Third Canadian Store at Vancouver’s Oakridge Park

Veronica Beard has opened its third Canadian store at Vancouver's Oakridge Park, building on strong growth in Toronto, Montreal, and online.

Fairmont Jasper Park Lodge unveils $100M transformation

This marks the latest in a series of investments by owner Oxford Properties in Canada, where the firm has committed more than $2 billion since 2025.

Inside the Brokerage Deals Reshaping Luxury Retail in Canada

Luxury retail expansion at Oakridge Park and Yorkdale is reshaping Canada’s retail landscape as brokerages help global fashion brands secure flagship locations in the country’s top luxury destinations.

Cellzy preparing for aggressive launch in Canada

A new modern retail concept focused on accessories, electronics and repair services, is preparing for an aggressive launch phase, with plans to open five new locations in 2026.

HEAL Wellness expands across Canada and U.S., targets 100 locations by end of 2026

What started as a single Ontario location has now grown to more than 37 locations across the country.

Big City Mayors call for federal action to bolster downtowns, drive economic growth

City leaders say revitalizing downtowns is central to broader national economic goals, with impacts on employment, business activity and community well-being.

Ocgrow Group expands into luxury hospitality with launch of premium hotel division

The company’s first hotel offering is located within Greystone, a 150-acre master-planned community where Ocgrow is the largest developer and landlord.

Retail and Grocery Leaders Honoured at RCCSTORE2026 Awards Programs

Retail Council of Canada recognized retailers, brands and industry leaders at RCCSTORE2026 through its Excellence in Retailing Awards and Canadian Grand Prix New Product Awards.

Creative Production Supports Retail Growth in Canada

Brandomatic Studios helps retailers scale creative production across digital and in-store channels with consistent execution.

Daily Synopsis: Jun 4, 2026

T&T Supermarkets opening at CF Sherway Gardens, MEC owner acquires Saint John Mall, Lululemon reports slower Canadian sales, Walmart launches Walmart+ membership in Canada, and other news.

Lululemon Sees Canadian Sales Decline as North American Growth Slows

Lululemon reported declining sales in Canada and lowered its annual outlook as the retailer works to rebuild momentum in North America amid growing competition.

T&T Supermarket to open at CF Sherway Gardens

T&T Supermarket will open at CF Sherway Gardens in Toronto, taking over the former Pusateri's and Saks Fifth Avenue food hall space.

MEC Owner Tim Gu Acquires McAllister Place Mall in Saint John

MEC owner Tim Gu has acquired McAllister Place in Saint John for $64 million, expanding Smart Investment's growing Canadian shopping centre portfolio. Craig Patterson speaks with Gu in an exclusive interview.

What Best Buy Says About Consumer Spending in Canada Right Now

Best Buy's latest results suggest Canadian consumers remain cautious and value-focused, but continue spending when products offer innovation and clear value.

Walmart+ membership launched in Canada

Canada is the first Walmart market outside of the United States to launch Walmart+.

Jacques Pérusse and Daughter Scale Teaology Across Canada

Beauty industry veteran Jacques Pérusse and daughter Valérie are expanding Teaology across Canada through major pharmacy retailers.

Charcoal Group pushes ahead with expansion as restaurant sector faces uncertainty: CEO Jody Palubiski

Consumers are still spending on dining out, but have become more selective about where they choose to go.

Sustainability-focused retailer HG Vintage weighs growth opportunities across Canada

Moe Khoja launched HG Vintage in 2019 after decades in conventional fashion retail.