The Bay vs. Holt’s: It’s Time for Label Wars…

Date:

Share post:

Canada’s two largest fashion retailers are in a sort of ‘label war’. The Hudson’s Bay Company (The Bay) and Holt Renfrew have been fighting to carry designers in a sparsly populated country where designer distribution is tightly controlled.  This ‘war’ will only intensify in anticipation of Nordstrom’s entry into Canada in late 2014, and furthermore as The Bay continues to upscale itself as a premiere fashion retailer. 

Ungaro gown in ‘The Room’ at Hudson’s Bay. Image used with permission by Rafael Escobar, owner of the blog Frock of Ages. [Image Source and Link]

Strolling through the second-floor of The Bay in Vancouver, for example, one finds numerous women’s designers available at both Holts and The Bay. To rattle off a few mutually-carried designers: Nina Ricci, Comme des Garcons, Balmain, Akris Punto, 3.1 Phillip Lim, Ralph Lauren Black Label, Nicholas Kirkwood shoes, Brian Atwood shoes, Vince, Diane von Furstenberg, Eileen Fisher, Elie Tahari, J-Brand Jeans, McQ by Alexander McQueen, Naked & Famous, Opening Ceremony, Theory and Z-Spoke Zac Posen. 

We’ll review menswear at both stores once The Bay’s sixth-floor men’s store is open in mid October. Again, expect some designer cross-over.

Shoe Shopping at The Bay in Vancouver (Image: thestylespy.com)

Our source at Vancouver’s Holt Renfrew tells us Holts has been scrambling to pick up some of the more upscale designers selling with some success at The Bay, including expensive designers Nina Ricci and Balmain, and shoe designers Brian Atwood and Nicholas Kirkwood. What’s interesting to note is The Bay’s pieces by these designers are generally more ‘out there’ and ‘unique’ compared to more subdued offerings by the same designers at Holt Renfrew.  This phenomenon is thanks a Bay buyer/creative director named Nicholas Mellamphy, who has carefully cultivated an avant garde, upscale image for The Bay’s luxury salon known as ‘The Room’. The Room is currently at Bay stores in Vancouver and Toronto, and will open tentatively next year in Montreal. 

The Bay has taken some women’s designers that Holt Renfrew has dropped, including DSquared2, Armani Collezioni, L’Wren Scott, Piazza Sempione, Moschino Couture and Thakoon. Our Holt Renfrew insider source notes that Armani Collezioni, DSquared2 and Piazza Sempione struggled at Holt Renfrew in Vancouver and were therefore dropped prior to being picked up by The Bay.

Readers in more remote parts of Canada may be surprised to hear that you can buy a $10,000 dress at The Bay. Readers can be assured that more remote Bay stores, some currently in awful shape, will be renovated via money raised from an initial public stock offering which is expected to happen between mid-October and the early New Year. 

Snakeskin Proenza Schouler bags, available at The Bay in Vancouver and Toronto. Price? If you have to ask, you can’t afford it… (ok fine, they’re just under $8,400 each)

We will keep you updated with various movements within Canada’s designer label availability, and we will start posting about where Canadians can find some premium designers. Be sure to follow us on Twitter and Facebook, as we sometimes provide insider retail information not posted on this website. 

Hudson’s Bay Company website: www.thebay.com

Holt Renfrew website: www.holtrenfrew.com

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

RELATED ARTICLES

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

RECENT articles

RioCan sees committed retail occupancy climb to 98.8% in Q2

Completed 1.0 million square feet of leasing in the Second Quarter, including 0.9 million square feet of renewals.

Retail Insider “Retail Logistics Report”: Optionality Replaces Lean Efficiency

Canadian retailers are redesigning supply chains for recurring disruption, trading some lean efficiency for diversified sourcing, stronger inventory visibility and more flexible fulfilment networks. Retail Insider’s Q2 2026 report examines the operating and competitive implications of this shift.

SportChek to open Destination Sport store at CF Chinook Centre as Calgary mall accelerates retail transformation

SportChek will consolidate its two CF Chinook Centre locations into a larger Destination Sport concept store in 2027 as the Calgary shopping centre adds new retailers including Shake Shack, Hollister, New Balance, and Wingstop while continuing its retail transformation.

Staples Canada launches annual school supply fundraising campaign supporting United Way, Kiwanis

The campaign, which runs until Sept. 27, allows customers to make donations at checkout in Staples stores across Canada.

New 50% U.S. tariffs add pressure on retailers as trade uncertainty disrupts pricing, inventory and growth: DOSS Report

A new DOSS report finds the latest 50% U.S. tariffs on Canadian goods are intensifying pressure on retailers, forcing companies to rethink pricing, inventory management and supply chains while delaying long-term growth plans.

Fairleigh Dickinson University Opening New Campus at Oakridge Park in Vancouver

Fairleigh Dickinson University will open a 70,000-square-foot Vancouver campus at Oakridge Park, bringing new weekday activity to the mixed-use development.

Fall Toronto Gift + Home Market Opens August 9: Everything Retail Buyers Need to Know

The Fall Toronto Gift + Home Market opens August 9 in Toronto, giving qualified retail buyers four days to discover suppliers, products and holiday merchandise.

Small businesses face mounting financial pressure: Merchant Growth

Ontario restaurants and small businesses are struggling with wildfire smoke, extreme heat, rising utility costs and new U.S. tariff threats. Merchant Growth's latest survey reveals growing financial strain, reduced U.S. trade and cautious consumer spending.

Leyad announces two senior appointments

Experienced leaders from First Capital REIT and Agellan join national real estate platform.

Air Canada and Hyatt Show Where Loyalty Partnerships Are Heading

Air Canada’s Aeroplan and World of Hyatt have announced a comprehensive loyalty partnership, offering members new ways to earn and redeem points. The partnership enables more integrated travel experiences across both platforms, enhancing customer loyalty.

Second Cup Appoints Joe Walker as CEO to Lead International Franchise Growth

Canadian-founded Second Cup has named Joe Walker CEO of its international franchise business as the company looks to expand its global footprint, with the Middle East serving as a strategic growth hub.

Daily Synopsis: Jul 31, 2026

Sleep Country completes Sleep Number acquisition, ranking Canada's grocery loyalty programs, Atlantic salmon prices jump in July, Giant Tiger shutting downtown Winnipeg store, Quebec gov't extends hours for 'erotic' stores, and other news.

What Couche-Tard Could Gain from Żabka Beyond 13,000 Stores

Couche-Tard’s Żabka acquisition adds more than 13,000 stores, while giving the Canadian retailer access to advanced convenience technology, compact formats and digital capabilities. Retail strategist Carl Boutet says the Polish convenience retailer’s compact stores, autonomous technology and digital capabilities could make the US$8.6-billion acquisition particularly significant for Couche-Tard’s global business.

Kate Spade New York names Tyla global brand ambassador as artist fronts fall campaign (Video)

The partnership will see Tyla featured in brand campaigns, social media content and in-store advertising, beginning with the fall campaign and continuing through additional promotional initiatives the company plans to unveil later this summer.

Casavogue Extends Summer Sale with Savings of Up to 50 Percent

Casavogue has extended its Summer Sale for a limited time, with savings of up to 50% across all categories and up to 60% on select liquidation pieces.

Couche-Tard reaches deal to acquire controlling stake in Poland’s Żabka Group in transaction valued at US$8.6 billion

If completed, the deal would be the largest acquisition in Couche-Tard's history.

Home Depot restructures leadership to streamline operations and accelerate growth strategy

At the end of the first quarter of fiscal 2026, the company operated 2,361 retail stores and more than 1,280 SRS locations across the United States, Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin Islands, Guam, all 10 Canadian provinces and Mexico.

Sobeys surpasses food waste reduction target five years ahead of UN goal

Empire said the food loss and waste reduction included 40.6 million pounds of food donated across Canada during fiscal 2026, while another 5.2 million pounds of food was diverted through the FoodHero program.

Employment in retail continues to increase: Statistics Canada

The monthly increase in May was concentrated in food and beverage retailers (+5,100; +1.0%), motor vehicle and parts dealers (+1,100; +0.5%) and general merchandise retailers (+1,000; +0.4%).

Loblaw Plans About 75 Store Openings in 2027 as Discount Expansion Continues

Loblaw expects to open about 75 stores in 2027 as it expands No Frills, Maxi and its pharmacy network amid sustained demand for discount grocery shopping.