Home Blog Page 67

40% of Canadians drinking more coffee today than a year ago: Field Agent report

William Fortunato photo
William Fortunato photo

Coffee remains one of Canada’s most deeply rooted daily rituals, but where, when and how Canadians drink it is evolving, says Jeff Doucette, General Manager, Field Agent Canada.

Between September 16 to 27, he said Field Agent Canada surveyed 1,410 Canadians to better understand today’s coffee occasion, from the kitchen counter to the drive-thru. 

The report, The Canadian Coffee Cup: How Canadians Are Drinking Coffee, At Home and Away in 2026, explored the habits shaping both the retail and foodservice coffee markets.

With National Coffee Day today September 29, Doucette highlighted some fun facts:

  • 91% of Canadians consume coffee on a regular basis.
  • 40% of Canadian coffee drinkers say that they are drinking more coffee today compared to one year ago.
  • Drip Coffee is still the most popular type (71%) but Iced Coffee is very popular as well with Canadian coffee drinkers (68%).
  • 45% of Canadian coffee drinkers consume Decaf Coffee at least some of the time, but only 1% drink Decaf exclusively.
  • 48% of Canadian coffee drinkers have a Keurig / K-Cup system in their home – the most popular type of coffee machine.
  • The top brands at-home are the same as out-of-home: Tim Hortons, Starbucks and McCafe.
  • The average Canadian coffee drinker consumes 1.3 coffee servings out-of-home (at a cafe / restaurant / on-the-go) per day.
  • 17% of Canadian coffee drinkers report that they regularly visit Independent / Local coffee shops.
  • Dunkin Donuts is coming back to Canada and Canadian coffee drinkers rated their likelihood of regularly visiting Dunkin’ at a 3.6, on a scale of 1 to 5.

The report said coffee remains deeply embedded in Canadian routines—and consumption is strengthening. 

“Consumption is highest in the morning and gradually declines through the day,” explained the report. 

“At-home consumption skews more strongly toward older consumers, while away-from-home participation rises from 84% among Boomers to 96% among Gen Z. The at-home market combines traditional coffee habits with considerable equipment and format diversity.

“Tim Hortons leads at-home brands at 25%, while Costco is the leading retail destination, used by 50% of respondents shopping for coffee to prepare at home. Away from home is a more varied, mobile and afternoon-oriented coffee occasion.”

Vitaly Gariev photo
Vitaly Gariev photo

The report said that drive-thru ordering is used by 64%, versus 51% ordering at a staffed counter, and 84% consume their purchased coffee in the car/on the go. 

“Away-from-home coffee also extends further into the afternoon than at-home consumption. Convenience is central, but coffee also creates a meaningful incremental food occasion. Tim Hortons dominates away-from-home purchasing at 82%, ahead of Starbucks at 62% and McCafé at 58%. Importantly for foodservice operators, a food item accompanies 28% of away-from-home coffee orders,” it said.

“Taken together, the study depicts Canadian coffee as an ecosystem spanning the kitchen, grocery shelf, drive-thru and café—with consumers moving fluidly between at-home convenience and away-from-home variety, portability and foodservice occasions.”

More from Retail Insider:

Bed Bath & Beyond returns to Canada with e-commerce launch

Bed Bath & Beyond photo
Bed Bath & Beyond photo

Bed Bath & Beyond is returning to the Canadian retail scene first as an e-commerce shopping platform and plans for brick-and-mortar stores to follow in late 2027.

“Bed Bath & Beyond has long held a special place in Canadian homes, and we’re excited to welcome it back for a new generation,” said Carol Deacon, President, Bed Bath & Beyond Canada. “We’ve taken what people know and love about the brand and given them new reasons to discover it, with a thoughtful assortment that brings together style, function and accessibility. This homecoming isn’t about looking backward. It’s about taking a name Canadians already know and trust forward.”

Sleep Country Canada acquired the brand’s rights in late 2025 after it shut down its stores. Bed Bath & Beyond Canada entered CCAA creditor protection in February 2023. At the time, it operated 54 stores.

“What makes a home feel truly yours is deeply personal,” added Deacon. “The most meaningful homes aren’t created by following a formula or a particular look. They’re shaped over time by the people who live there, their routines, their traditions, their personalities and the moments that matter to them. We want to help Canadians create homes that feel unmistakably their own.”

Bed Bath & Beyond Canada launches with about 6,000 products from over 80 brands across eight categories, with greater depth in bedding and bath to serve as the go-to destination for Canadians’ home needs. Categories span bed, bath, kitchen, dining, décor, organization, baby, seasonal and more, it explained.

“The assortment has been intentionally built for the Canadian market, balancing trusted everyday essentials with fresh finds across a range of styles and price points. It brings together established global brands and Canadian favourites, alongside the return of select internationally recognized home brands. Underpinning the assortment is a belief that there is no single way to create a beautiful home, with enough choice to help Canadians find the products and styles that feel right for them,” said the retailer.

Bed Bath & Beyond Canada said it offers a more curated approach to home, bringing together trusted brands, design-forward products and unexpected finds across bed, bath, kitchen, décor and beyond.

Stewart Schaefer, President & CEO of Sleep Country Canada as well as SleepCountry, Dormez-vous, Endy, Hush, Silk & Snow, Casper, Simba, and Sleep Number, said bringing Bed Bath & Beyond back to Canada is a dream come true for him.

“And what makes this moment even more exciting is that we’re not simply bringing back a familiar name — we’re building something new for Canadians. We know bed. We know bath. And now, this is the next chapter,” he said.

“Across the Sleep Country family, we’ve spent years helping Canadians create homes they love. Bringing Bed Bath & Beyond into our family gives us the opportunity to do even more — across more rooms, more categories and more moments at home. This is a BIG step for our business and an exciting one for Canadian retail.

“I’m incredibly proud of the team that brought this vision to life, and I can’t wait for Canadians to see what we’ve built.”

More from Retail Insider:

Bed Bath & Beyond photo
Bed Bath & Beyond photo
Bed Bath & Beyond photo
Bed Bath & Beyond photo

CF Market Mall Partners With Grey Cup For Interactive Football Experience 

Cadillac Fairview photo
Cadillac Fairview photo

CF Market Mall is launching a new football experience in partnership with  the Grey Cup.

The Huddle, a free, hands-on football experience, will take over the popular Calgary mall from October 5 to October 18.

Visitors of all ages are invited to test their quarterback skills over target practice, measure their vertical jump, tackle a blocking sled, and try out a digital football simulator during the two-week event hosted in Grand Court and Centre Court, said Cadillac Fairview which operates the shopping centre.

“We’re thrilled to bring the energy of the CFL and the start of football season to our mall this October,” said Paige O’Neill, General Manager, CF Market Mall. “With The Huddle, we’re creating a vibrant, fun-filled experience where local sports fans and shoppers can come together to celebrate their love of the game in an entirely new way.”

Cadillac Fairview photo
Cadillac Fairview photo

Here’s what’s happening at The Huddle:

  • Skill Challenges & Simulator: Precision target throws, jump tests, blocking sleds, and a digital football simulator.
  • CFL Athlete & Mascot Appearances: Scheduled autograph sessions, photo ops, and meet-and-greets featuring CFL players, alumni, and team mascots.
  • Custom Player Card Photo Ops: Free personalized player cards printed on site from 1:00 PM to 5:00 PM on October 10–11 and October 17–18.

Cadillac Fairview said the free event runs during regular mall operating hours, and is open to participants of all ages and skill levels. For schedule details and guest appearance announcements, visit https://shops.cadillacfairview.com/property/cf-market-mall.

More from Retail Insider:

Food services and drinking places sales reach close to $9 billion in July: Statistics Canada

Los Muertos Crew photo
Los Muertos Crew photo

Total sales in the food services and drinking places subsector increased 0.8% in July to $8.9 billion, the seventh consecutive monthly increase, according to a report by Statistics Canada.

Non-seasonally adjusted prices for food purchased from restaurants were up 2.9% in July compared with July 2025. Unadjusted prices for alcoholic beverages served in licensed establishments increased 3.5% over the same period, said the federal agency.

In July, the largest increase in sales in dollar terms came from full-service restaurants (+0.8%), the industry’s seventh consecutive month-over-month increase. Special food services (+3.8%) had the largest percentage increase, following a decline of 1.0% in the previous month. Sales at limited-service eating places (+0.4%) and drinking places (+0.9%) also increased.

Sales increased in seven provinces in July, with the largest increase in dollar terms coming from Ontario (+0.8%), followed by Quebec (+1.4%) and Alberta (+1.8%). In dollar terms, the largest decrease came from British Columbia (-0.4%).


Ivan S photo
Ivan S photo

But a recent report noted that Canada’s restaurant industry continues to feel the pain as consumers, strapped financially these days, are eating out less.

Restaurants Canada said 80% of Canadians are eating out less often due to the rising cost of living, up from 75% a year ago. Restaurants Canada’s 2026 Foodservice Facts report said the biggest jump is in households earning $100,000 or more (78% compared to 70% in 2025).

Despite this, Canadians continue to find ways to frequent restaurants, making 24 million restaurant visits daily. Six in 10 Canadians (61%) say they would visit a table-service restaurant more often if they had more disposable income, up from 53% in 2025, demonstrating the important role restaurants play in the day-to-day lives and quality of life of Canadians, said the report.

More from Retail Insider:

Canadian coffee consumption evolving

Second Cup photo
Second Cup photo

Coffee consumption in Canada is evolving. Cold beverages are now popular year-round, while consumers are constantly exploring new flavours and formats. Expectations for convenience, value and sustainability are higher than ever.

With National Coffee Day today September 29 and International Coffee Day on October 1, Deena Nezirevic, senior product manager at Second Cup, provides insight into current Canadian coffee preferences and the factors shaping the market.

What coffee flavours, beverages and formats are currently gaining the most traction with Canadian consumers?  

Coffee is such a fun ingredient to work with because it is so adaptable. It pairs well with many flavours and there are endless beverage applications. We continue to see a lot of global influence on flavours from Asia, Latin American, the Middle East and North Africa – from pistachio, sesame, yuzu, pomegranate, horchata and more. A love for nostalgia continues with flavours like PB & J, Nanaimo Bar and Banana Bread but it’s evolving into Newstalgia blending classic flavours with emerging one, and we’re seeing them used in espresso-based beverages, cold brew and RTD (Ready-to-Drink) coffee. Beyond flavour, texture is gaining a lot of traction. Layering with a velvety cold foam or topping with a crunchy garnish, all to enhance the drinking experience.  

Being that it’s the fall season, I would be remiss to not talk about Pumpkin Spice. This flavour continues to be relevant even after 2+ decades. It’s a nod to the changing season. Love it or hate it, it symbolizes a return to cozy and comfort and it’s a must have on the menu. How it’s evolving is through new beverage applications like Second Cup Café’s Iced Matcha with Pumpkin Spice Cold Foam, but you can’t not include the classic, Pumpkin Spice Latte.

How are younger consumers influencing café menus, particularly in terms of customization, new flavours and cold beverages? 

The younger consumer’s influence on café menu development is huge. Their gateway into coffee drinking is cold coffee, often starting their taste journey with sweet and creamy drinks that mildly resemble coffee and gradually progressing to coffee-forward cold beverages.    

Customization is critical for any coffee house. Younger consumers want to make it their way.  It’s that opportunity to make it uniquely yours, a custom creation, adapted for me. In Full-Service Restaurants, you might see a menu notation ‘no substitutions, best enjoyed how the Chef intended’. That won’t work in a café environment. It would alienate too many, especially the younger consumer. They are also the ones who are driving innovation and LTOs (Limited Time Offers)  thanks to their desire for new, eagerness for taste adventure, and, of course, the influence of  social media.

Second Cup recently released an Espresso Mocktini, our take on a classic Espresso Martini. This is in response to younger consumers fueling the demand for healthier options like non-alcoholic beverages and functional drinks like protein coffee. Yet, on the other side of the spectrum, they are often driven to the counter trend of over-the-top indulgence.   

How has the growing popularity of cold coffee beverages changed the way Canadians consume coffee throughout the year?  

Cold coffee is no longer just a summertime beverage. At Second Cup, we see the gradual shift in our sales mix, year over year, away from drip and hot espresso-based drinks to cold coffee. Cold beverage options are essential year-round, and you’ll see them featured on Second Cup’s seasonal menu even in the dead of winter! Consumers enjoy soda year-round. Why should cold coffee be different?   

How are factors such as value, convenience, customization and sustainability influencing Canadians’ coffee purchasing decisions?  

These are all critical factors right now affecting Canadians’ purchasing decisions and how brands are designing menus and creating offers to encourage visits. Canadians love their coffee and they will continue to enjoy it despite the rising cost of living.  What is changing is how and where they enjoy it.  

We see growth in the at-home barista. They’ve invested in coffee equipment and are buying beans from shops like Second Cup, other local cafés or direct from roasters. For those who continue to purchase their coffee away-from home, convenience is key. Customization and community are critical drivers as well. A warm interaction and custom-crafted beverage go a long way. For others, it’s a hybrid of at-home vs. away-from home.  A visit to the coffee shop might be to treat yourself or for a special occasion.  It’s easier on the budget than a night out for dinner. Climate change and the impact on coffee growing regions is undeniable. Protecting the future of coffee, the financial sustainability for farmers and the environmental sustainability for the lands on which they harvest, are critical for the future of coffee.

August de Richelieu photo
August de Richelieu photo

What emerging trends do you expect will have the biggest impact on Canadian coffee and café culture over the next few years? 

Canada’s café culture will continue to be vibrant, innovative, and community focused. Many Canadians are craving connection and human interaction. The coffee shop fills that void and will continue to with vibrancy and warmth. What better way to build community and make people feel seen than through a great cup of coffee and welcoming atmosphere?

From a menu development standpoint, global influence and food tourism will continue to have a huge impact but you don’t need a plane ticket to experience it. Explore in your own city by visiting local cafés and restaurants that are doing great things.   

I expect Mood Food, the functional food trend, will continue to evolve in new ways. Consumers want efficient and delicious ways to get more out of their food and drink.  We saw that with protein, collagen, hydration and the next might be fibre, although not the sexiest to market. Prebiotics sounds catchier. I like to think that coffee is the original energy drink. It’s clean energy too and there are endless ways to enjoy it.   

More from Retail Insider:

Skip teams up with Domino’s

Domino's photo
Domino's photo

Delivery service Skip continues to grow its partnership base. The company has now added Domino’s, a leading pizza brand, to its network.

As Canadians settle into their September routines, balancing back-to-school schedules, busy weeknights and fall gatherings with friends, pizza remains a crowd-pleasing choice. With Domino’s now available on Skip, Canadians can easily order their go-to pizzas and sides for whatever the occasion calls for, said the company in a news release.

“Joining forces with Domino’s is all about delivering maximum flavour and ultimate convenience to our customers,” said Paul Sudarsan, Senior Vice President of Partnerships at Skip. “We’re constantly expanding our network with iconic brands that Canadians love, making it simpler than ever to get great value delivered fast.”

The company said Canadians can enjoy 30% off their first three Domino’s orders on Skip, up to $9 off per order, on orders of $30 or more with code DOMINOS30, from September 21 through November 1.

“We couldn’t be more excited to partner with Skip to bring Canadians their favourite pizzas from Domino’s,” said Ken Harrison, Chief Commercial Officer at Domino’s Pizza of Canada. “By utilizing Skip’s platform while having Domino’s Delivery Experts deliver every order, even more Canadians can get the Domino’s experience they know and love.”

Domino's photo
Domino’s photo

With more than 5 million customers, 50,000+ partners and availability in 450+ cities across Canada, Skip continues to grow its selection of national brands. 

Domino’s, which opened in Canada in 1983, has more than 650 locations in Canada. Domino’s Pizza of Canada Ltd. is a privately held company and is the Canadian Franchisee of Domino’s Pizza International Franchising, Inc. of Ann Arbor, Michigan. Founded in 1960, Domino’s Pizza ranks among the world’s top public restaurant brands with a global enterprise of more than 17,000 stores in over 90 markets.

More from Retail Insider:

Are The Best Retail Brands Playing Moneyball?

Every retail founder knows the stalemate. Profit margins are thin. Customer acquisition costs are high. Retention is stuck. They’ve switched agencies, tried new dashboard vendors.  But the numbers barely move. Over time, those numbers start to feel like the norm. Everyone works hard, but no one can break the stalemate.

But retailers are having a moneyball moment.

In sports, moneyball isn’t just about data and statistics. It’s about identifying metrics with the highest leverage.  Overlooked signals like “on base percentage”.  Where minimal effort drives maximal output.

In retail, the principle is the same. It’s about getting 20% of your customers to drive 80% of your growth.  Finding high-leverage metrics requires a new set of skills.

Turning a retail brand into an elite retail brand requires five disciplines: fixing data sprawl; rallying the business around LTV:CAC; using SMART analytics to find high-leverage metrics; getting a return on analytics spend; and building a healthy data culture.

  1. Solving Data Sprawl

Most retailers don’t have a data shortage problem. They have a “data sprawl” problem.  Marketing data in Meta, Google, and TikTok. Order data in Shopify, Amazon, and Target.  Customer data in Salesforce, Klaviyo, and Twilio.  Financial data in Netsuite, QuickBooks, and Excel.  Disconnected SaaS systems that each reveal a narrow piece of the business, but none explains the whole.

Solving it means building a data model connecting ad spend, orders, customers, and subscriptions data. It requires a mix of technologies and techniques.  Technologies like Fivetran, Snowflake, Tableau, Python, and Claude. Techniques like ETL, software architecture, SQL modeling, dataviz, and agentic AI.

Once data sprawl is solved, retail brands gain powerful multi-source metrics that are more complex, more nuanced, and more illuminating to the cause of transforming the business.

  1. Getting to LTV:CAC

The LTV:CAC ratio is a major unlock for retailers.  Joining many marketing sources into CAC and many revenue sources into LTV is difficult.  Vendors that downplay this complexity overpromise their capabilities.  But once retail brands figure this out, they unlock huge revenue opportunities.

LTV:CAC empowers retail brands to understand the undercurrents driving their business.  LTV:CAC is not just a number, it is a story. It is a set of techniques that elite retail brands use to find high leverage metrics.

One technique is grouping customers by acquisition date – or “LTV cohort” – to track how customers’ value evolves, and to reveal differences in repeat purchases, margins and seasonality that company-wide averages hide.

Another technique is “CAC payback” that quantifies how long it takes to recover acquisition costs. First orders can lose money and still lead to profitable cohorts, assuming there are enough repeat purchases.  It helps finance set sustainable marketing budgets.

Another technique is “predictive LTV” – which uses statistical models like Buy Till You Die to forecast whether customers will return, how often they will purchase, and how much future revenue they may generate.

  1. Doing SMART Analytics

“SMART Analytics” is a framework developed by Latticework Insights to identify high leverage metrics that drive outsized business results. It looks at five customer dimensions:

  • Speed: How fast customers repurchase?
  • Margin: Which factors – like COGS, discounts, shipping, duties, and freight – drag on profitability?
  • Attribution: Which marketing channels drive purchases?
  • Retention: What drives repeat purchase behavior?
  • Tiers: What are the different segments of customer behavior?

SMART analytics helps brands identify moneyball opportunities, where small changes can have high leverage impacts on growth.

  1. Return on Analytics Spend (ROAS)

Retailers expect ad agencies to earn a multiple on every dollar.  So why don’t they ask the same question of analytics teams?  Elite retail brands don’t treat analytics as a cost center. They treat it as a mission critical discipline that finds high leverage metrics that create new revenue opportunities.  

Elite retail brands get a return on analytics spend.

Their teams have domain expertise across marketing, finance, and operations that enable them to see novel patterns in the data and model potential scenarios to improve revenue growth.

  1. Creating a Healthy Data Culture

The hardest discipline in analytics isn’t a data problem, it’s a people problem.  When teams disagree, when trust in dashboards is low, when meetings end without clear next steps, there is an unhealthy data culture.  A healthy data culture facilitates teamwork, insights, and action.

Elite retail brands establish common definitions of success. Their analytics, marketing, finance, and operations teams team up to find high leverage insights.

Like moneyball they make experimentation the norm, and let evidence change the lineup. They are prepared to change a campaign, budget, or longstanding practice when new insights warrant it.

What makes an Elite Retail Brand?

An elite retail brand isn’t defined by revenue. It’s defined by mastering disciplines to see clearly and act decisively.

They reconnect their data, understand LTV:CAC, use SMART analytics, demand a return on analytics spend, and have a healthy data culture.

So, are the best retail brands playing moneyball?

Absolutely.  But just like in sports, they’ve combined analytics with intuition, leadership with accountability.  They experiment and cooperate.  And when they find a high leverage insight, they galvanize their whole team.

The next breakthrough for your retail brand is hiding somewhere in your current dashboards.

Find the insight, rally your team, and change the game.

How GPS Tracking Helps Retailers Stop Supply Chain Theft

A pallet of electronics leaves a distribution center on a Tuesday night. By Wednesday morning it should be at a store two states away. Instead, the truck is sitting in a lot nobody planned for, and the cargo is already being unloaded. Retailers know this story well. Theft between the warehouse and the shelf costs money, and it also breaks promotions, empties shelves and damages customer trust.

The good news is that most of this theft depends on one thing: nobody watching. A fleet tracker installed on trucks and trailers changes that. It shows where every vehicle is, how long it has been stopped and whether it is still on the route you approved, so a problem can be caught while it is happening, not three days later in a spreadsheet.

Where Theft Actually Happens

People imagine dramatic highway robberies, but a lot of losses are quieter. Drivers take unauthorized stops. Loads get partly unloaded at a “friendly” location. Trailers get dropped in a yard and picked up by someone else. Sometimes an insider tips off the people who steal. Every one of these has a gap in visibility at the center, and that gap is exactly what GPS closes.

Real-Time Location Beats Guesswork

Live tracking lets a dispatcher see a truck moving on a map instead of trusting a phone call. If a vehicle sits still for forty minutes in an unfamiliar area, someone can call the driver right away. If the driver doesn’t answer, the team already has a live location to hand over to the police. Recovery chances are much better in the first hour than in the first day, and that is why speed matters so much here.

Geofences Do the Watching for You

Nobody can stare at a map all day. Geofencing solves this by drawing virtual boundaries around warehouses, approved stops, stores and known risky zones. When a truck enters a place it shouldn’t, or leaves the route corridor, an alert goes to your phone or inbox. You stop checking everything and only react to what looks wrong.

Trailer and Cargo Tracking

Tracking the truck alone isn’t enough, because thieves love to unhook a trailer and leave. Battery-powered trackers hidden on trailers, containers or even high-value pallets keep reporting after the cab is gone. Pair them with door sensors and you will also know when the doors open at a time they shouldn’t.

Driver Behavior and Route Discipline

GPS data also shows patterns. A route that keeps taking longer than it should, frequent detours, or repeated idling in the same spot are all worth a conversation. Most drivers are honest, and clear data actually protects them, because a false accusation is easy to disprove when the trip history is on record. Over time, the fact that everyone knows trips are tracked discourages small acts of theft before they begin.

Evidence When You Need It

When theft does happen, records make everything easier. Time-stamped location history helps with police reports, supports insurance claims and can speed up settlements. Some insurers also offer better terms to companies that can show real security measures, so the device can partly pay for itself.

Getting Started Without Overcomplicating It

You don’t need to track everything on day one. Start with the routes and products that are stolen most, such as electronics, cosmetics, branded apparel and alcohol. Set sensible alert rules, since too many alerts get ignored, and decide in advance who responds and how. Then expand as you see results.

Final Thoughts

Supply chain theft thrives on blind spots. GPS tracking removes them, giving retailers live visibility, faster response and solid records. It won’t stop every attempt, but it makes your shipments a much harder target, and thieves usually prefer easier ones.

Why Skipped Orders Cost Subscription Retailers More Than Cancellations: YOCTO (Opinion)

By George Kapernaros, founder of YOCTO, a retention agency for subscription and DTC brands, named Klaviyo Elite Master, 2025-2026.

Every subscription brand I work with reviews cancellations weekly. Almost none of them review deferrals at all. That is backwards. Across the 100+ subscription accounts my team analyzed this year, deferrals are often a bigger problem than cancellations. On some accounts they cost four times as much.

What a Deferral Actually Is

A deferral is a delayed payment. A customer skips the next box, pauses for a month, or pushes the billing date out to something that suits them better.

It slips under the radar because it is not a cancellation. The subscriber still counts as active. The churn report stays clean. No save flow fires, no win-back email goes out, and nothing in the Monday numbers looks wrong. The money simply does not arrive.

Retailers have a name and a dashboard for every other kind of loss: shrink, markdowns, returns, failed payments. Deferred revenue is the one line most subscription operators cannot produce on request.

Most subscription platforms will show it to anyone who looks. The forecast view that projects the next 30 days of billings usually separates expected revenue from cancellations, failed payments and deferrals, as three distinct lines. Very few operators open it, and fewer still put it in front of a finance team.

The Revenue That Never Shows Up as Churn

Here is what it costs in practice. One account billing over $10 million a month in subscriptions is forecast to miss a large share of next month’s book. Cancellations account for 16% of that miss. Failed payments account for another 15%. Deferrals are the remaining 69%, roughly $2.5 million a month. A meal-delivery client projected $307,000 in billings over 30 days and collected about $200,000. Cancellations explained $25,000 of the $107,000 gap. Almost all of the rest was people pressing skip.

Neither brand had a retention problem it could see. Both had one they were paying for.

Deferrals Distort More Than Revenue

A cancellation at least tells the business something. It takes a customer out of the forecast, releases the inventory allocated to them and updates the demand plan. A deferral does none of that. The customer stays in the count, the units stay committed, and the cash does not arrive on the date the plan assumed. For a subscription retailer buying stock against a billing schedule, that is a working-capital problem as much as a marketing one. You order for a cohort that is still nominally active, hold product against orders that were quietly pushed a month out, and then find the gap in the bank rather than in the dashboard. Revenue that arrives late, or never, behaves a great deal like a customer who pays late. It is just as expensive and far harder to chase, because nothing in the system flags it as overdue.

Skips Cluster at the Second and Third Order

The timing makes it worse. In the accounts we reviewed, 14% of subscribers skip their second order and 18% skip their third.

That is the exact window where a subscription is supposed to turn into a habit. The first delivery proves the product works. The second and third prove the schedule works. Instead, roughly a sixth of every cohort quietly opts out of the part that decides whether they are still a customer in month six.

A Skip Is Rarely a Pause

The uncomfortable part is what happens next. Very few people who defer come back.

A skip is usually the polite version of leaving. No confrontation, no cancellation flow, no reason given. The customer gets to avoid the decision, and you get to avoid the data. Your subscription platform reads it as retention. Your bank statement reads it correctly a quarter later.

This is also why reported churn and felt churn never match. Our published subscription benchmarks put median annual churn, counting pauses, at 55.8%. Operators who quote me 20% are almost always quoting cancellations only, which is why their forecast and their deposits keep disagreeing.

The behaviour does respond to being taken seriously. On one account, rebuilding the cancellation flow around the reason the customer actually gave, instead of one blanket discount for everybody, moved the save rate from 4.17% to 42.34%. The product did not change and neither did the price. The same logic applies to skips, which almost nobody builds a flow for at all.

What This Means for Canadian Retailers

Canadian operators are already watching shoppers trade down, buy smaller baskets and shop more often. That behaviour does not stop at the subscription box. A household under cost pressure rarely cancels a subscription it still believes in. It skips one month, then another, and by the third skip it has replaced the habit with something cheaper.

If you run a replenishment, meal, wellness or pet subscription, four questions are worth putting to your team this week:

  • How much revenue is deferred over the next 30 days, and how does that compare with what we expect to lose to cancellations?
  • What share of subscribers skip their second order?
  • Of the customers who skipped once last quarter, how many have billed since?
  • How many taps does it take a paused customer to restart?

If nobody can answer the first question, that is the finding.

Four Changes That Close the Gap

  1. Measure it. Put deferred revenue next to cancelled revenue for the next 30 days, in the same report, every week. A number nobody owns is a number nobody fixes.
  2. Treat a skip like a cancellation. Ask the reason before offering anything, then answer the reason they actually gave. “Too much product” is an interval problem, not a price problem. Discounting someone who did not leave over price just teaches a happy customer to cancel for a coupon.
  3. Make resuming one tap. If coming back means a login, a password reset and a re-checkout, the skip was permanent and you have not noticed yet.
  4. Track return rate by skip number. A first skip and a third skip are different customers, and only one of them is still winnable.

The Number You Are Not Looking At

Across the accounts we analyzed, soft churn was the largest single leak and the least instrumented one. This is not a problem retailers are choosing to ignore. It is one their tooling does not show them, because the industry built its dashboards around the customers who announce that they are leaving.

Your churn number only describes the people who bothered to tell you.

Daily Synopsis: September 28, 2026

Welcome to the Daily Synopsis by Retail Insider. We hope you enjoy the 10 articles we published covering key developments in Canadian retail. Here are a couple highlights with a full list of the day’s articles thereafter.

The Competition Bureau is investigating minimum advertised pricing policies in the Canadian grocery sector, concerned that these rules may hinder price competition and prevent consumers from seeing the lowest prices, despite discounts being available in-store. Slate Grocery REIT has agreed to a $2.3 billion all-cash buyout by a joint venture between Brixmor Property Group and Everview Partners, offering unit holders a premium price and immediate liquidity. Sunterra Group has closed its Red Deer market, marking its second store closure this year amid court-supervised restructuring under the Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act.

Sports Experts invested approximately $8 million to renovate its 45,000-square-foot Carrefour Laval flagship, enhancing inventory capacity, customer navigation, and e-commerce fulfillment while concentrating on high-margin categories like footwear, which has driven strong early sales gains. Pharmacy Brands Canada has expanded to over 300 locations nationwide, with significant growth in Ontario.

🗞️ The Day’s Retail Insider Article List

🌐 Canadian Retail News From Around the Web