Pusateri’s Fine Foods Unexpectedly Closes at Bayview Village in Toronto, Little Italy Store Opening Shelved

Date:

Share post:

Pusateri’s Fine Foods, a stalwart of upscale grocery shopping in Toronto, has abruptly closed its location at Bayview Village Shopping Centre without explanation. The company has also closed the grocery component of its Saks Food Hall downtown while shelving plans for a store in Little Italy.

The Bayview Village closure, which caught shoppers off guard this week, comes just months after Pusateri’s shuttered its Yorkville store, ending a two-decade presence in one of Toronto’s most affluent neighbourhoods.

Efforts to obtain clarity on the situation have yielded little information — Retail Insider called the Avenue Road store, which had no answers. A call to landlord QuadReal also provided more questions than answers.

Following publishing this article, Streets of Toronto confirmed that the Bayview Village Pusateri’s has closed permanently — and as well, plans for a location that was under construction in Little Italy in Toronto have also been shelved, despite ongoing construction.

Prior to the confirmation, Retail Insider noted Google indicating that the Bayview Village Pusateri’s location is now permanently closed.

It also appears that the grocery component to the Saks Food Hall in downtown Toronto is no longer operating, though vendors with concessions are currently selling according to a source.

The sudden closure of the Bayview Village Pusateri’s location — previously considered one of the company’s leading stores in terms of sales — has raised questions about the challenges facing high-end food retailers in an increasingly competitive and economically uncertain landscape. It also appears that there may be a bigger issue within Pusateri’s itself.

The upscale food market in Toronto has become increasingly crowded in recent years. Eataly, the Italian mega-market, has announced plans for its fourth location in the city, set to open in early 2025 at the CF Toronto Eaton Centre — and earlier this year, a smaller location opened south of Bayview Village at CF Shops at Don Mills. 

Pusateri’s Fine Foods at Bayview Village in Toronto. Photo: Pusateri’s

Pusateri’s, founded in 1963 by Sicilian immigrant Salvatore Pusateri, has long been synonymous with gourmet food shopping in Toronto. The company’s transformation from a modest produce stand to a high-end grocery empire mirrored the city’s own evolution into a global culinary destination.

However, recent years have seen the company facing headwinds. In addition to the Yorkville and Bayview Village closures, Pusateri’s shuttered its Oakville location in 2018 after just two years of operation, and closed its food hall at Saks Fifth Avenue at CF Sherway Gardens in 2023.

The company had previously announced plans to open a new 10,000-square-foot store in Little Italy, touted as a return to its roots. However, that location, initially slated to open in the summer of 2023, has faced ongoing delays and now won’t be opening at all.

Given the information, we’ll follow up on this story when we learn more about what is happening with Pusateri’s Fine Foods.

6 COMMENTS

  1. They’ve also, as of the end of the business day on August 9th, closed the interior portion of their Queen Street Saks Food Hall. They’ve left the perimeter businesses (fritters, eclairs, noodle bar, poké, bahn mi, coffee shop, and pizza) running Monday to Friday. Everything is now closed on weekends. Rumours are that the family is fighting over their money.

  2. Eataly works for reasons i simply don’t understand – it’s a weekend destination for hordes of people, but the overall quality is far below Eataly’s attention to presentation.

    Pusateri’s strikes me as having overextended its reach – the Saks venture was dreary from the outset: who is food shopping in the below ground level of The Bay, and their prices were not an attraction.

    I was a daily coffee bar habitue at the Yorkville store for the past 15 years, but a year or two pre-Covid, there was a marked deterioration of service, attention to keeping the store neat and tidy, and a revolving door of staff who rarely had the time to smile.

    • who were food shopping in the below ground level? well before covid … all the financial people were down there buying food and socializing. was very lively!

Comments are closed.

RELATED ARTICLES

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

RECENT articles

Cozy Earth Founder Tyler Howells on Building a Global Bedding Brand and Expanding Into Loungewear and Canada

Tyler Howells started Cozy Earth back in 2011 after growing up dreaming about making the world's softest sheets...

Canadian Watch Marketplace Dialist Takes Aim at Luxury Resale Market

Mississauga-based Dialist is entering the North American luxury watch resale market with a platform combining dealer listings, authentication, transaction protections and servicing. The Canadian startup is targeting buyers and independent dealers across Canada and the U.S.

Black Friday Advertising: Retailers Cut Ad Spending as Consumer Purchase Intent Rises: Teads

Teads data shows Black Friday ad click-through rates rise to 1.82% as advertiser spending drops more than 30%, highlighting opportunities for Canadian retailers.

Made with Local launches protein snack squares produced in Nova Scotia

The Canadian snack company is introducing four flavours of its 40-gram Little Treat squares, with online sales beginning at $36.50 per 12-piece carton.

Northboys and Northgirls Expand as Sales Rise 28% and Hudson’s Bay Exit Creates Opportunity

North Brands Group has opened a 3,000-square-foot combined Northboys and Northgirls store at Upper Canada Mall in Newmarket. The retailer reports 28% sales growth in 2025 and says Hudson's Bay's closure has created new opportunities.

Why Successful Retailers Can Be Hiding Serious Operational Weaknesses

Canadian supply chain specialist Gary Newbury explains how strong retail sales and expansion can conceal costly operational weaknesses, from inaccurate inventory records to recurring supply-chain interventions.

Stem Health Eyes GTA Expansion After Opening 8,000-Square-Foot Toronto Flagship

Stem Health has opened an 8,000-square-foot healthcare clinic at First Canadian Place in Toronto. Founder and CEO Ashim Khemani tells Retail Insider the company is scouting a second location, with ambitions for multiple GTA facilities and eventual expansion elsewhere in Ontario.

More Canadians report financial strain heading into holiday season: Money Mart

A Money Mart survey finds 26 per cent of Canadians feel less confident about holiday spending, while six in 10 plan to reduce expenses amid inflation and trade tensions.

Shoppers Want AI to Help Them Shop, Not to Fix Their Problems or Fake Their Photos: Baymard

New survey by Baymard of 2,273 US online shoppers finds two-thirds want a human when an order goes wrong, and 60% lose confidence in products shown with AI-generated images.

Daily Synopsis: November 18, 2026

Metro CEO says winning back consumers is a priority, Competition Bureau investigates Old Navy and the Gap over pricing. claims, Loblaw allows users to buy groceries with Meta AI, Dressew prepares to close in Vancouver, and other news.

Gucci’s Price Cuts Expose a Bigger Problem for Luxury Fashion

Gucci's selective handbag price reductions are raising questions about luxury fashion's pricing power. As Coach and Hermès report stronger results, the industry's uneven performance is reshaping the debate over product desirability, aspirational customers and investment in Canadian luxury retail.

Trove Wellbeing Expanding to The James in Toronto as Founders Eye International Growth

Toronto-based Trove Wellbeing is opening its second location at The James in Summerhill, with approximately 5,000 square feet of wellness facilities planned for February 2027. Co-founders Tanya Kololian and Zoë Paliare discuss their backgrounds, the concept's membership strategy, and ambitions to expand into the U.S. beginning in 2028.

Toronto Clinic Lume Women + Health Launches Physician-Led Women’s Health Service Focused on Preventive Care

Lume Women + Health is introducing a sex-specific healthcare model in Toronto, combining physician-led assessments with multidisciplinary support for women throughout adulthood.

Okta Report: 71% of Canadians Would Abandon Retail Apps Over Unauthorized AI Actions

Canadian consumers want control over AI shopping agents, with new Okta research revealing concerns about unauthorized purchases, privacy and customer loyalty.

METRO sees sales growth but net earnings decline in Q4 and Fiscal 2026

METRO said net earnings of $886.1 million, for the year were down 13.1% and adjusted net earnings of $949.6 million, down 9.5%.

Cyberattacks on European Supermarkets Expose Food Supply Chain Security Risks: Cybersecurity Expert

Hackers have remotely manipulated supermarket refrigeration systems across Europe, raising concerns about cybersecurity risks to food retailers and supply chains.

AutoCanada Targets Lower Real Estate Costs as It Rethinks Canadian Dealership Expansion

AutoCanada is reassessing its Canadian dealership portfolio, prioritizing lower real estate costs, regional clusters and stronger financial returns following three B.C. dealership sales.

Pink Martini Opens 4,000-Square-Foot Toronto Warehouse Café

Toronto fashion brand Pink Martini Collection has opened a 4,000-square-foot warehouse café in North York, combining discounted fashion, current collections, refreshments and private events beside its existing distribution operation.

Gen Z and Millennials Drive 2026 Holiday Retail Trends as Crafts, Games and Grannycore Decor Surge: Faire

Gen Z and millennials are reshaping 2026 holiday shopping, driving demand for crafts, games, puzzles, nostalgic decor and global food trends, according to Faire.

Foodtastic wins Platinum MarCom Award for Dunkin’ Canada return campaign

Foodtastic receives international recognition for its bilingual communications campaign announcing a master franchise agreement to bring Dunkin’ back to Canada.