Why Successful Retailers Can Be Hiding Serious Operational Weaknesses

Date:

Share post:

A retailer can be growing sales, opening stores and meeting customer-service targets while operational weaknesses accumulate behind the scenes. Employees may spend additional hours verifying inventory, managers may repeatedly intervene to resolve routine problems, and distribution teams may expedite merchandise to compensate for processes that are not working as intended.

These interventions can protect customers and maintain revenue, but they consume resources that may not be fully visible in performance reports. Canadian supply chain specialist Gary Newbury says the consequences become particularly important when retailers expand, introduce technology or encounter unexpected disruptions.

“Sales can grow while the operation becomes more expensive, demanding and dependent on exceptional effort,” Newbury told Retail Insider in a written interview. He argues that executives need to understand the work required to achieve apparently healthy results, particularly when evaluating operating costs and future growth.

Newbury, principal of Supply Chain Specialists Canada, calls this condition organizational drift, describing how businesses gradually accommodate weaknesses instead of correcting their underlying causes.

Gary Newbury

How Organizational Drift Develops

Newbury’s professional background spans commercial finance, business turnarounds, growth, integration and operational leadership. Across those activities, he says he repeatedly encountered organizations where capable employees maintained performance despite persistent operational weaknesses.

A manual inventory check might prevent a customer from ordering unavailable merchandise, while additional warehouse handling could ensure promotional products reach stores before an advertised sale. An experienced manager might personally resolve recurring issues that established processes should ordinarily handle.

These interventions can be necessary when customer commitments are at risk. Problems emerge when organizations become dependent on them without investigating why they are repeatedly required.

Newbury defines organizational drift as a condition in which an organization accommodates, adapts around or compensates for identifiable weaknesses instead of correcting them promptly at their source. He has developed the concept in Organizational Drift: A Field Guide for Senior Leaders, which he makes available without charge.

His framework distinguishes between an underlying weakness, the activity protecting performance and the dependency that develops when employees repeatedly compensate for it. Unlike improvement initiatives triggered by missed targets, his approach can begin with results that appear acceptable but require increasing resources or repeated intervention.

The Hidden Work Behind Retail Performance

Inventory management illustrates how recurring workarounds can affect retail operations. Newbury describes a hypothetical situation in which employees manually verify stock before accepting online pickup orders because inventory records are unreliable for certain products.

The additional check protects customers, but creates work that accurate inventory information could eliminate. As pickup volumes increase, the business may become more dependent on employees who know which records can be trusted.

Independent research demonstrates that inventory inaccuracies can have measurable commercial consequences. A July 2026 study published in the Journal of Business Logistics examined approximately 24,000 stock-keeping units across 11 stores operated by a major UK grocery retailer.

Researchers found relationships between inventory inaccuracies and factors including stock levels, replenishment frequency and product perishability. A separate quasi-experimental component involving one matched pair of stores found that an inventory audit was associated with an approximately 11% increase in store-wide sales over the following two months.

The improvement was concentrated among products where recorded inventory exceeded actual stock. However, the limited experimental setting restricts how broadly the sales findings can be applied.

Additional research published in November 2026 by IHL Group examined the labour associated with inventory reliability. Its analysis drew on a survey of 2,200 store associates across seven countries, including Canada, conducted by Sapio Research in partnership with IHL Group and Scandit.

Associates reporting inventory accuracy between 31% and 70% spent an average of 30.4 hours weekly on eight inventory-related tasks, compared with 25.9 hours among those reporting accuracy above 70%. The difference of approximately 4.5 hours reflects an association in employee-reported conditions, not proof that inventory inaccuracies alone caused the additional work.

For Newbury, the concern is that executives may see acceptable results without understanding the resources employees are using to achieve them. “The result reaching the executive team may conceal the work required to produce it,” he said.

A store might borrow merchandise from another location, a supervisor might reorganize staffing, or a distribution manager might intervene personally to ensure an order reaches its destination. The customer receives the merchandise and the performance measure remains acceptable, while additional costs and dependencies may go unnoticed.

Why Expansion Can Expose Existing Weaknesses

These issues become particularly relevant when retailers expand their store networks, acquire businesses or increase their e-commerce capabilities. Processes that function across a limited number of locations can become difficult to manage as transaction volumes grow.

“Expansion tests whether the existing arrangements can scale,” Newbury said. Manual inventory allocations, informal communication and reliance on experienced employees may face additional pressure across a larger network.

He describes expansion, acquisitions, leadership departures and operational disruptions as potential Exposure Events. Within his framework, these developments reveal or intensify weaknesses previously managed through compensating activities.

An acquisition may introduce different inventory systems, merchandising practices and distribution requirements. If the acquiring business already depends on informal processes, integrating another network could increase complexity and the resources needed to manage it.

The departure of an experienced manager can create similar difficulties when that person has been informally coordinating decisions across departments. Problems may appear suddenly, although the underlying dependency developed over a longer period.

For Canadian retailers considering new locations, distribution investments or acquisitions, these questions have implications for expansion costs and execution. Opening stores increases demands on inventory systems, warehouse capacity, transportation and the employees coordinating those activities.

When Supply Chain Problems Cross Departmental Boundaries

Some weaknesses develop between departments, where individual performance measures do not necessarily reflect the outcome experienced by customers. Newbury points to promotional merchandise as an example requiring coordination between merchandising, buying, inventory allocation, transportation, distribution centres and stores.

A merchandising team may approve an offer based on expected availability, while distribution operations face capacity limitations or shipment delays. Store employees may then rearrange schedules, expedite receiving activities or transfer merchandise between locations to get products onto the sales floor.

Each department might report acceptable performance against its own measures, even though merchandise was unavailable when customers expected to purchase it. Newbury recommends following a promotion from the original commercial decision through to the customer, examining where assumptions changed, who received updated information and which employees had authority to respond.

The approach can also distinguish external disruptions from weaknesses in a retailer’s internal response. A supplier delay may be outside the retailer’s control, but slow detection, unclear allocation priorities or inadequate communication with stores can increase its consequences.

Conversely, a missed operating target may reflect an unrealistic expectation or a constraint that cannot be economically overcome. For retailers managing transportation and labour costs, distinguishing market pressures from recurring internal interventions can influence decisions about staffing, inventory investment and operating margins.

The Risks of Automating Weak Processes

Artificial intelligence and automation introduce another consideration: technology can reproduce weaknesses already present in business processes and underlying information. Newbury uses automated replenishment to illustrate the problem.

A system examining sales history might identify a product with no recorded sales for three consecutive days and interpret the result as declining demand. Those missing sales could instead reflect an empty shelf, inaccurate inventory records or merchandise recorded in the wrong location.

Inventory inaccuracies predate contemporary AI applications. A 2021 study published in the International Journal of Production Economics examined inventory record inaccuracies and store-level performance at an international fashion retailer, reinforcing the importance of reliable operational information without evaluating contemporary AI systems.

Newbury believes technology can improve productivity when retailers understand the processes being automated and the information supporting decisions. Before introducing new systems, he recommends establishing accountability, determining how errors will be detected and corrected, and testing technology under difficult operating conditions.

For retailers investing in AI-supported forecasting, inventory management and supply-chain operations, these considerations connect technology spending directly to the reliability of existing processes.

What Retail Leaders Should Examine

Newbury believes executives can begin identifying organizational drift by examining the actual work required to deliver important business outcomes. One approach is to select an objective, such as having promotional merchandise available at the beginning of an advertised sale, and trace recent examples through the operation.

Leadership can then identify recurring interventions, establish why they occurred and determine whether the business has become dependent on them. Frontline employees are particularly important because their experience may reveal problems absent from management reports.

Newbury suggests asking staff during store or distribution centre visits what they regularly have to do to make operations work that someone reviewing performance reports would never see. The answers can reveal where employees are compensating for inaccurate information, unclear responsibilities, insufficient capacity or processes that no longer meet business requirements.

Once a weakness is identified, Newbury recommends evaluating its current costs, potential future exposure and the benefits of correction. Leadership should then assign responsibility, determine an appropriate response and measure whether changes reduce the effort required to maintain performance.

Not every weakness requires immediate correction, and Newbury acknowledges that deliberate deferral can be reasonable when executives understand the consequences and establish accountability. He also cautions against removing temporary workarounds before correcting the problems that made them necessary, since eliminating an inventory check prematurely could create customer-service failures if the underlying records remain unreliable.

“Strong performance is more valuable when the business understands what makes it reliable and can sustain it as conditions change,” Newbury said. His advice is to examine the people and processes protecting current results before assuming those arrangements can support the next stage of growth.

More From Retail Insider

RELATED ARTICLES

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

RECENT articles

Stem Health Eyes GTA Expansion After Opening 8,000-Square-Foot Toronto Flagship

Stem Health has opened an 8,000-square-foot healthcare clinic at First Canadian Place in Toronto. Founder and CEO Ashim Khemani tells Retail Insider the company is scouting a second location, with ambitions for multiple GTA facilities and eventual expansion elsewhere in Ontario.

More Canadians report financial strain heading into holiday season: Money Mart

A Money Mart survey finds 26 per cent of Canadians feel less confident about holiday spending, while six in 10 plan to reduce expenses amid inflation and trade tensions.

Shoppers Want AI to Help Them Shop, Not to Fix Their Problems or Fake Their Photos: Baymard

New survey by Baymard of 2,273 US online shoppers finds two-thirds want a human when an order goes wrong, and 60% lose confidence in products shown with AI-generated images.

Daily Synopsis: November 18, 2026

Metro CEO says winning back consumers is a priority, Competition Bureau investigates Old Navy and the Gap over pricing. claims, Loblaw allows users to buy groceries with Meta AI, Dressew prepares to close in Vancouver, and other news.

Gucci’s Price Cuts Expose a Bigger Problem for Luxury Fashion

Gucci's selective handbag price reductions are raising questions about luxury fashion's pricing power. As Coach and Hermès report stronger results, the industry's uneven performance is reshaping the debate over product desirability, aspirational customers and investment in Canadian luxury retail.

Trove Wellbeing Expanding to The James in Toronto as Founders Eye International Growth

Toronto-based Trove Wellbeing is opening its second location at The James in Summerhill, with approximately 5,000 square feet of wellness facilities planned for February 2027. Co-founders Tanya Kololian and Zoë Paliare discuss their backgrounds, the concept's membership strategy, and ambitions to expand into the U.S. beginning in 2028.

Toronto Clinic Lume Women + Health Launches Physician-Led Women’s Health Service Focused on Preventive Care

Lume Women + Health is introducing a sex-specific healthcare model in Toronto, combining physician-led assessments with multidisciplinary support for women throughout adulthood.

Okta Report: 71% of Canadians Would Abandon Retail Apps Over Unauthorized AI Actions

Canadian consumers want control over AI shopping agents, with new Okta research revealing concerns about unauthorized purchases, privacy and customer loyalty.

METRO sees sales growth but net earnings decline in Q4 and Fiscal 2026

METRO said net earnings of $886.1 million, for the year were down 13.1% and adjusted net earnings of $949.6 million, down 9.5%.

Cyberattacks on European Supermarkets Expose Food Supply Chain Security Risks: Cybersecurity Expert

Hackers have remotely manipulated supermarket refrigeration systems across Europe, raising concerns about cybersecurity risks to food retailers and supply chains.

AutoCanada Targets Lower Real Estate Costs as It Rethinks Canadian Dealership Expansion

AutoCanada is reassessing its Canadian dealership portfolio, prioritizing lower real estate costs, regional clusters and stronger financial returns following three B.C. dealership sales.

Pink Martini Opens 4,000-Square-Foot Toronto Warehouse Café

Toronto fashion brand Pink Martini Collection has opened a 4,000-square-foot warehouse café in North York, combining discounted fashion, current collections, refreshments and private events beside its existing distribution operation.

Gen Z and Millennials Drive 2026 Holiday Retail Trends as Crafts, Games and Grannycore Decor Surge: Faire

Gen Z and millennials are reshaping 2026 holiday shopping, driving demand for crafts, games, puzzles, nostalgic decor and global food trends, according to Faire.

Foodtastic wins Platinum MarCom Award for Dunkin’ Canada return campaign

Foodtastic receives international recognition for its bilingual communications campaign announcing a master franchise agreement to bring Dunkin’ back to Canada.

Daily Synopsis: November 17, 2026

Meat, cheese and luxury clothing top targets for thieves say police, Quebec retail employees deal with rudeness and harassment, curling rink becomes grocery store in Manitoba, and other news.

Home Depot reports 4.9% sales growth in third quarter, raises fiscal 2026 outlook

Home Depot reported US$43.4 billion in third-quarter sales, with comparable sales rising 2.2%, and expects full-year sales growth of approximately 4.5%.

Canadians curb Black Friday spending as affordability pressures squeeze household budgets: Harris & Partners

A Harris & Partners survey found 87.4 per cent of respondents made no unplanned Black Friday purchases in 2025, raising questions about whether spending restraint reflects better budgeting or financial pressures.

REYAL Founder Reflects on Five Years of Growth, Retail Lessons and U.S. Expansion

Five years after launching REYAL Performance, founder Tanner Johnston discusses the Canadian self-care brand's growth into more than 500 retail locations, lessons from wholesale expansion, Amazon economics, self-funding and plans to grow in the United States through fitness partnerships.

Monica Vinader Opens at Holt Renfrew in Toronto and Calgary as Former CEO Sebastian Picardo Leads Canadian Expansion

British jewellery brand Monica Vinader has opened shop-in-shops at Holt Renfrew in Toronto and Calgary. CEO Sebastian Picardo, who previously led the Canadian luxury retailer, discusses the company's selective distribution strategy, plans for additional Canadian locations, and expansion into new jewellery categories.

Bailey Nelson’s Hotel Bailey Pop-Up Drives 1 Million Social Impressions in Vancouver

Bailey Nelson turns its Vancouver eyewear store into an immersive hotel-themed retail experience, boosting customer engagement and generating strong sales results.