Okta Report: 71% of Canadians Would Abandon Retail Apps Over Unauthorized AI Actions

Date:

Share post:

Canadians would let AI request a refund or cancel a subscription if they can approve it first, but few would let it make a purchase for them. That’s according to new data from Okta’s Customer Identity Trends 2026 report, as AI agents move from answering questions to taking action this holiday season.

Ryan Sydor, AVP and Canada Country Manager at Okta, said businesses are moving quickly to introduce AI agents, but many consumers are still deciding how much responsibility they’re comfortable handing over. 

“56%% of Canadians say AI in apps and websites is moving too fast, compared with 52% across the seven countries surveyed. Meanwhile, 59% of organizations in our global survey already have an agent in production or in the pipeline,” he said.

“For retailers, the risk is getting ahead of what customers want AI to do for them, and what they still want to maintain control of. A shopper may welcome help finding a product without wanting an agent to buy it for them. Businesses can bridge that gap by starting with smaller, clearly explained features and asking permission before expanding what an agent can do. The pace should reflect customers’ comfort as well as the technology’s capabilities.”

Potential impact on customer loyalty

Two-thirds of Canadian consumers want to retain control over AI-driven decisions, while 71% say they would stop using an app or website if its AI took actions they had not approved. 

Permission is becoming part of the customer experience. An AI feature may be designed to save someone time, but if it acts without their approval, that convenience can quickly become a reason to leave, said Sydor.

“71% of Canadians say they would stop using an app or website if its AI took unapproved actions, and 40% would stop using it entirely if it acted on their behalf without telling them. Those findings make this a customer retention issue as much as a technology decision.

Brands need to be clear about what an agent can do, when it needs permission and what it has done on a customer’s behalf. Loyalty built over years can be put at risk by an interaction that leaves someone feeling they’ve lost control,” he said.

Building consumer confidence

The findings suggest Canadians are more comfortable with AI when they can switch it off, require permission before actions are taken, or reach a human when needed. What specific measures should retailers and other businesses implement to build consumer confidence while continuing to expand their use of AI?

“Give customers controls they can easily find and use. That means asking for approval before an agent makes a purchase, changes an account or shares personal data, and making it straightforward to switch AI off or reach a person,” explained Sydor.

“In the report, 37% of Canadians say permission settings such as “ask me first” would make them more comfortable, while 34% want the option to reach a human.

“Behind those customer controls, businesses also need clear limits on the agents themselves. Each agent should have its own identity, with access restricted to the task it needs to complete. The business should be able to identify which agent is acting, on whose behalf and what it is allowed to do. Customer confidence depends on both visible choices and the security supporting them.”


Mikhail Nilov photo
Mikhail Nilov photo

Financial transactions particularly sensitive 

The report identifies purchasing decisions and financial transactions as particularly sensitive areas, with only 5% of Canadians willing to let AI independently make purchases under both the $25 and $100 thresholds. 

Helping someone shop and spending their money are very different levels of responsibility, said Sydor.

“Retailers should build confidence through tasks such as finding products, comparing options and putting together a cart, while keeping customers in control of the purchase while trust is built,” he said.

“61% of Canadians say they would never allow AI to make purchases over $100 independently. As retailers introduce more purchasing capabilities, customers should be able to choose whether to use them and understand exactly what they’re authorizing. A quick, secure approval step, such as a confirmation on their device, can let an agent simplify things while leaving the final decision with the shopper.”

Priorities for Canadian businesses 

Despite consumer caution, 63% of Canadians say they are more comfortable with AI acting on their behalf than they were a year ago, and 55% would give AI more control over time if it consistently performed well.

Trust will grow through experience: does the agent do what the customer asked, respect their limits and ask before going further? The finding that 55% of Canadians would give AI more control if it consistently performed well gives businesses a clear direction, added Sydor.

“Start with a defined task, deliver reliably and let customers decide when they’re ready to delegate more. Over the next 12 to 24 months, businesses should strengthen the security foundations that support those experiences, including secure sign-up and login and multi-factor authentication,” he said.

“They also need to establish how they manage agents’ access. Giving each agent its own identity, with tightly scoped, time-limited access, helps keep its permissions aligned with its task, but only 22% of organizations building AI features use that approach today. Putting those controls in place now will help businesses prepare as customers become comfortable asking agents to do more.”

More from Retail Insider:

Mario Toneguzzi
Mario Toneguzzi
Mario Toneguzzi, based in Calgary, has more than 40 years experience as a daily newspaper writer, columnist, and editor. He worked for 35 years at the Calgary Herald covering sports, crime, politics, health, faith, city and breaking news, and business. He is the Co-Editor-in-Chief with Retail Insider in addition to working as a freelance writer and consultant in communications and media relations/training. Mario was named as a RETHINK Retail Top Retail Expert in 2024.

MORE FROM AUTHOR

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

Related articles