How to Turn Your Subscribers Into Loyal Customers

Date:

Share post:

By Greg Zakowicz, Senior Commerce Marketing Analyst, Bronto

Consumers are checking their email more often, and on more devices, than ever before. It’s not hard to see that email remains one of the most effective ways to reach customers. For savvy marketers, meeting consumers at this vital touchpoint is an opportunity that can’t be ignored.

But when it comes to consistently growing subscriber databases and maintaining subscriber engagement, the struggle – as they say – is real. Marketers often make the mistake of focusing on acquiring the sign-up, and then reverting to a generic batch-and–blast messaging strategy. But this causes your subscribers to disengage earlier. They expect you to send them relevant, personalized experiences. And if you don’t deliver, you can wave goodbye to those subscribers you worked so hard to acquire.

So, how do you grow your list size in a way that will help you collect the right customers and keep them engaged?

Be Consistent – and Creative

When looking to steadily grow your contact database, you need to take a consistent, multi-pronged approach. There are a few ways you can do this. First, include a sign-up above the fold of your homepage, or even better, on all pages of your site. This gives consumers an easy way to sign up while browsing on your site. This is especially important if they link directly to a product page from the web. Limiting the signup to only the homepage decreases your ability to secure a new subscriber.

You’ll also want to consider popups, dropdowns, and ribbons. These strategies are front and center to new visitors and are routinely the most effective list-growth tactics. Of course, don’t ignore other areas of growth: Include social pages, co-registration partnerships, and brick-and-mortar stores.

Now to address the elephant in the room: Should you offer an incentive for singing up? The answer is – it depends. Be wary of training your customers to wait for discounts to make purchases. You can always get creative when it comes to what to offer: A free gift with their next purchase, a weekly or monthly raffle for a gift card or other prize for new signups, or even partner with a cause that is meaningful to your subscribers – which is another great way to personalize.

For example, if your brand sells men’s underwear, consider supporting a testicular cancer foundation. Promote and communicate this cause on your website, and ask them to sign-up to receive more information on how they can help get involved. You can even provide a “coupon code” to use at checkout that will allow that discount to be donated, rather than taken off the purchase price. This way the consumer becomes emotionally connected, and the brand can track the effectiveness of the campaign.

Get Personal

You’ve acquired new subscribers. Now it’s time to personalize their experience. Regardless of the products you sell – men’s underwear, cookies or car parts – personalization (even on a small scale) can have a deep and lasting effect. It can be the difference between keeping subscribers engaged – or having them hit “unsubscribe.”

The good news is that difference is entirely up to you. Even if you are using a batch-and-blast email strategy, look for areas where you can maximize personalization and create a bond with your customer. This could be acquisition source (on-site), email or purchase behavior. If you know your subscriber signed up to receive emails while viewing men’s shoes, your welcome message or series should have a high focus on men’s shoes. Include intuitive product recommendations in your batch-and-blast messages – making them immediately more relevant. If users click on a maternity link inside of your emails, they should be sent emails focused on maternity items. If they are a recent purchaser, helpful tips on how to care for a newly purchased product is a great way to build trust and provide value to a customer.

The best part of all of this is that this can all be automated, taking a large burden off your team.

Make Them Believers

Commerce marketing isn’t about acquisition versus retention – it’s a combined strategy. You want to acquire the right customer and then engage them effectively along the way by showing that your brand understands them.

Focusing on your overall strategy will help get the right message, to the right customer, at the right time. This is where using segmentation, automation, send frequency and personalization can help.  

Remember: One-size-fits-all might work for concert t-shirts, but it rarely – if ever – works for email.

Oracle + Bronto arms high-growth retailers with sophisticated marketing automation to maximize revenue opportunities. The Bronto Marketing Platform powers personalized multichannel content that generates the higher engagement needed for retail success. Keenly focused on the commerce marketer, Bronto continues its longstanding tradition as a leading email marketing provider to the global Internet Retailer Top 1000 and boasts a client roster of leading brands, including Rebecca Minkoff, Timex, Lucky Brand, Theory, Brooks Sports, Ashley Homestore and Christopher & Banks. For more information, visit bronto.com.

*****

*Partner content. To work with Retail Insider, contact Craig Patterson at: craig@retail-insider.com.

RELATED ARTICLES

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

RECENT articles

Why Canadian Retailers Are Losing Sales They’ve Already Won

Checkout friction can cost Canadian retailers thousands in sales. Konek can help merchants offer a simple and trusted payment experience.

La Cordée Closure Ends Six-Year Turnaround Attempt in Quebec Outdoor Market

Quebec outdoor retailer La Cordée is shutting down after 73 years, ending a six-year turnaround that included new ownership and store expansion. The retailer returned to creditor protection in July 2026 with more than $13 million in obligations.

Tsawwassen Mills Marks 10 Years with H Mart, TM Wander and New Entertainment Uses

Tsawwassen Mills marks 10 years as Central Walk expands the 1.2-million-square-foot centre with TM Wander, recreation and entertainment uses. A roughly 30,000-square-foot H Mart anchor is also targeted to open around Christmas 2027.

IKEA Canada celebrates 50 years in Canada

To mark the milestone, IKEA Canada is focused on affordability with 50% off one iconic IKEA product every weekend in October.

Canadian Retail Supply Chains Face Scrutiny as $63.3B in Imports Linked to Labour Risk

World Vision estimates $63.3 billion in Canadian imports were associated with documented child- or forced-labour risks in 2025, led by electronics and apparel, as Ottawa considers stronger border enforcement that could raise traceability demands for retailers.

Iconic outdoor lifestyle brand L.L.Bean reimagines its flagship store in Freeport, Maine

The reimagined Flagship store and campus, which is visited by many Canadian tourists each year,  immerses customers in the outdoor lifestyle inspired by Maine and surrounds them with the products designed to enjoy it.

CF Chinook Centre adding three major retailers

Old Navy, SportChek and Winners will be joining the tenant mix at Calgary's most popular shopping centre.

Honestly Good Chicken Fingers and Serruya Private Equity Announce Joint Venture to Fuel Global Growth

New partnership will support expansion of the Canadian-born restaurant brand across North America and international markets

Niagara Falls Tourism Faces Weather Challenges as Rain and Flooding Hit 2026 Summer Season

Niagara City Cruises says poor weather has reduced walk-up visits while committed travellers remain resilient, with operators looking to the fall shoulder season. Niagara City Cruises says poor weather has reduced walk-up visits while committed travellers remain resilient, with operators looking to the fall shoulder season.

Iconic Colombian coffee brand Juan Valdez expands to Canada

Juan Valdez is entering Canada for the first time as part of its North American expansion strategy, bringing the quality, origin and heritage of 100% Colombian premium coffee to Canadian consumers.

Daily Synopsis: September 30, 2026

Canada's Weston family moves to acquire UK chemist Boots for $9bn, The Brick sells Scarborough site, Ikea opens small-format London ON store, Fortinos opens Popcorn Kitchen in Brampton store, Pattison calls out grocery store violence in BC, and other news.

Primaris REIT Announces $411 Million Acquisition of Upper Canada Mall

990,114 square foot mall located on 76 acres of land in the Greater Toronto Area.

Salesforce Brings AI Agents Closer to Checkout and Store Inventory at Dreamforce

Salesforce expands agentic commerce at Dreamforce 2026, connecting AI agents with checkout, store inventory and customer data as adoption grows in Canadian retail.

Canada’s Retail Market Is Polarizing. Where Does That Leave the Middle?

Canada’s retail market is increasingly polarized between value and premium. Linda Farha examines why differentiation, positioning and a clear customer proposition are becoming critical for retailers caught in the middle.

Preparing Retail for the Age of Autonomous Commerce: Why Trust and Fraud Prevention Matter

As AI shopping agents emerge, retailers face new challenges around fraud, trust and authentication. Here's what merchants should know about preparing for autonomous commerce.

Grocery Inflation Tests Brand Loyalty as Parents Trade Down to Store Brands: DOSS

DOSS research finds parents are cutting or replacing children’s favourite grocery products as higher prices push families toward cheaper alternatives.

Quartz Co. Plans Broader Canadian Retail Expansion with New Montréal Store

Quartz Co. is opening a new Montréal boutique as the Canadian outerwear brand considers Toronto, expands its women's business and navigates U.S. tariffs.

New Private Event Space in Toronto’s Entertainment District to open as UP Events

Located above PAI on Duncan Street, the new venue will pair a flexible event space with curated menus by chef Nuit and culinary experiences from across the By Chef Nuit restaurant portfolio.

How familiar breakfast foods continue to outperform: OEB Breakfast

"Something doesn’t need to be complicated to be special.

AI Hiring Tools Help Retailers Tackle Holiday Season Staffing Challenges: Hirevue

HireVue’s Dina Taylor discusses how retailers can use AI to screen candidates, identify job-relevant skills and streamline high-volume hiring.