How to Turn Your Subscribers Into Loyal Customers

Date:

Share post:

By Greg Zakowicz, Senior Commerce Marketing Analyst, Bronto

Consumers are checking their email more often, and on more devices, than ever before. It’s not hard to see that email remains one of the most effective ways to reach customers. For savvy marketers, meeting consumers at this vital touchpoint is an opportunity that can’t be ignored.

But when it comes to consistently growing subscriber databases and maintaining subscriber engagement, the struggle – as they say – is real. Marketers often make the mistake of focusing on acquiring the sign-up, and then reverting to a generic batch-and–blast messaging strategy. But this causes your subscribers to disengage earlier. They expect you to send them relevant, personalized experiences. And if you don’t deliver, you can wave goodbye to those subscribers you worked so hard to acquire.

So, how do you grow your list size in a way that will help you collect the right customers and keep them engaged?

Be Consistent – and Creative

When looking to steadily grow your contact database, you need to take a consistent, multi-pronged approach. There are a few ways you can do this. First, include a sign-up above the fold of your homepage, or even better, on all pages of your site. This gives consumers an easy way to sign up while browsing on your site. This is especially important if they link directly to a product page from the web. Limiting the signup to only the homepage decreases your ability to secure a new subscriber.

You’ll also want to consider popups, dropdowns, and ribbons. These strategies are front and center to new visitors and are routinely the most effective list-growth tactics. Of course, don’t ignore other areas of growth: Include social pages, co-registration partnerships, and brick-and-mortar stores.

Now to address the elephant in the room: Should you offer an incentive for singing up? The answer is – it depends. Be wary of training your customers to wait for discounts to make purchases. You can always get creative when it comes to what to offer: A free gift with their next purchase, a weekly or monthly raffle for a gift card or other prize for new signups, or even partner with a cause that is meaningful to your subscribers – which is another great way to personalize.

For example, if your brand sells men’s underwear, consider supporting a testicular cancer foundation. Promote and communicate this cause on your website, and ask them to sign-up to receive more information on how they can help get involved. You can even provide a “coupon code” to use at checkout that will allow that discount to be donated, rather than taken off the purchase price. This way the consumer becomes emotionally connected, and the brand can track the effectiveness of the campaign.

Get Personal

You’ve acquired new subscribers. Now it’s time to personalize their experience. Regardless of the products you sell – men’s underwear, cookies or car parts – personalization (even on a small scale) can have a deep and lasting effect. It can be the difference between keeping subscribers engaged – or having them hit “unsubscribe.”

The good news is that difference is entirely up to you. Even if you are using a batch-and-blast email strategy, look for areas where you can maximize personalization and create a bond with your customer. This could be acquisition source (on-site), email or purchase behavior. If you know your subscriber signed up to receive emails while viewing men’s shoes, your welcome message or series should have a high focus on men’s shoes. Include intuitive product recommendations in your batch-and-blast messages – making them immediately more relevant. If users click on a maternity link inside of your emails, they should be sent emails focused on maternity items. If they are a recent purchaser, helpful tips on how to care for a newly purchased product is a great way to build trust and provide value to a customer.

The best part of all of this is that this can all be automated, taking a large burden off your team.

Make Them Believers

Commerce marketing isn’t about acquisition versus retention – it’s a combined strategy. You want to acquire the right customer and then engage them effectively along the way by showing that your brand understands them.

Focusing on your overall strategy will help get the right message, to the right customer, at the right time. This is where using segmentation, automation, send frequency and personalization can help.  

Remember: One-size-fits-all might work for concert t-shirts, but it rarely – if ever – works for email.

Oracle + Bronto arms high-growth retailers with sophisticated marketing automation to maximize revenue opportunities. The Bronto Marketing Platform powers personalized multichannel content that generates the higher engagement needed for retail success. Keenly focused on the commerce marketer, Bronto continues its longstanding tradition as a leading email marketing provider to the global Internet Retailer Top 1000 and boasts a client roster of leading brands, including Rebecca Minkoff, Timex, Lucky Brand, Theory, Brooks Sports, Ashley Homestore and Christopher & Banks. For more information, visit bronto.com.

*****

*Partner content. To work with Retail Insider, contact Craig Patterson at: craig@retail-insider.com.

RELATED ARTICLES

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

RECENT articles

Trove Wellbeing Expanding to The James in Toronto as Founders Eye International Growth

Toronto-based Trove Wellbeing is opening its second location at The James in Summerhill, with approximately 5,000 square feet of wellness facilities planned for February 2027. Co-founders Tanya Kololian and Zoë Paliare discuss their backgrounds, the concept's membership strategy, and ambitions to expand into the U.S. beginning in 2028.

Toronto Clinic Lume Women + Health Launches Physician-Led Women’s Health Service Focused on Preventive Care

Lume Women + Health is introducing a sex-specific healthcare model in Toronto, combining physician-led assessments with multidisciplinary support for women throughout adulthood.

Okta Report: 71% of Canadians Would Abandon Retail Apps Over Unauthorized AI Actions

Canadian consumers want control over AI shopping agents, with new Okta research revealing concerns about unauthorized purchases, privacy and customer loyalty.

METRO sees sales growth but net earnings decline in Q4 and Fiscal 2026

METRO said net earnings of $886.1 million, for the year were down 13.1% and adjusted net earnings of $949.6 million, down 9.5%.

Cyberattacks on European Supermarkets Expose Food Supply Chain Security Risks: Cybersecurity Expert

Hackers have remotely manipulated supermarket refrigeration systems across Europe, raising concerns about cybersecurity risks to food retailers and supply chains.

AutoCanada Targets Lower Real Estate Costs as It Rethinks Canadian Dealership Expansion

AutoCanada is reassessing its Canadian dealership portfolio, prioritizing lower real estate costs, regional clusters and stronger financial returns following three B.C. dealership sales.

Pink Martini Opens 4,000-Square-Foot Toronto Warehouse Café

Toronto fashion brand Pink Martini Collection has opened a 4,000-square-foot warehouse café in North York, combining discounted fashion, current collections, refreshments and private events beside its existing distribution operation.

Gen Z and Millennials Drive 2026 Holiday Retail Trends as Crafts, Games and Grannycore Decor Surge: Faire

Gen Z and millennials are reshaping 2026 holiday shopping, driving demand for crafts, games, puzzles, nostalgic decor and global food trends, according to Faire.

Foodtastic wins Platinum MarCom Award for Dunkin’ Canada return campaign

Foodtastic receives international recognition for its bilingual communications campaign announcing a master franchise agreement to bring Dunkin’ back to Canada.

Daily Synopsis: November 17, 2026

Meat, cheese and luxury clothing top targets for thieves say police, Quebec retail employees deal with rudeness and harassment, curling rink becomes grocery store in Manitoba, and other news.

Home Depot reports 4.9% sales growth in third quarter, raises fiscal 2026 outlook

Home Depot reported US$43.4 billion in third-quarter sales, with comparable sales rising 2.2%, and expects full-year sales growth of approximately 4.5%.

Canadians curb Black Friday spending as affordability pressures squeeze household budgets: Harris & Partners

A Harris & Partners survey found 87.4 per cent of respondents made no unplanned Black Friday purchases in 2025, raising questions about whether spending restraint reflects better budgeting or financial pressures.

REYAL Founder Reflects on Five Years of Growth, Retail Lessons and U.S. Expansion

Five years after launching REYAL Performance, founder Tanner Johnston discusses the Canadian self-care brand's growth into more than 500 retail locations, lessons from wholesale expansion, Amazon economics, self-funding and plans to grow in the United States through fitness partnerships.

Monica Vinader Opens at Holt Renfrew in Toronto and Calgary as Former CEO Sebastian Picardo Leads Canadian Expansion

British jewellery brand Monica Vinader has opened shop-in-shops at Holt Renfrew in Toronto and Calgary. CEO Sebastian Picardo, who previously led the Canadian luxury retailer, discusses the company's selective distribution strategy, plans for additional Canadian locations, and expansion into new jewellery categories.

Bailey Nelson’s Hotel Bailey Pop-Up Drives 1 Million Social Impressions in Vancouver

Bailey Nelson turns its Vancouver eyewear store into an immersive hotel-themed retail experience, boosting customer engagement and generating strong sales results.

Leon’s Eyes Further Appliance Canada Expansion in Western Canada as Commercial Sales Grow

Leon's Furniture is considering additional Western Canadian locations for Appliance Canada after positive results from its Richmond, B.C., operation. Commercial appliance growth is also benefiting from existing construction projects and opportunities created by a competitor's departure.

CEBA Repayment Deadline Looms as Canadian Small Businesses Face Year-End Cash Crunch

Canadian retailers face a December 31, 2026 deadline to repay outstanding CEBA loans. New federal accounts show $7.2 billion in outstanding loans, while Vistance Accounting founder Daryl Ching warns that holiday cash-flow demands and refinancing constraints could complicate repayment.

SportChek’s Sales Productivity Improves as Fanwear and Triangle Loyalty Gain Momentum

SportChek's reporting segment increased sales per square foot by 5.8% despite a smaller store network in Q3 2026. Fanwear contributed about one-third of comparable-sales growth, while Canadian Tire reported record Triangle loyalty penetration at SportChek.

Canadian Kids’ Snack Brand Wellness Monster Secures First Seed Funding Round

Founded by former Mars executive Brittany Compton, Wellness Monster is expanding its Canadian retail presence with new investment, growing distribution and innovative kids’ snacks.

Boston Pizza Reports Record Sales as Canadian Restaurant Expansion Remains Limited

Boston Pizza reported record third-quarter franchise sales of $257.5 million despite limited Canadian restaurant expansion. The company opened one restaurant and permanently closed four through September 2026, while completing 34 renovations across its existing network.