Visiting an Amazon 4-Star Store – Herd Mentality or Shopping Made Easy?

Date:

Share post:

I was in New York over the holidays and visited the Amazon 4-Star store in SoHo. Overall, the store was functional but not incredibly exciting from my perspective. The visit also led me to contemplate the limitations of such a concept and to challenge the very meaning of it in society. A little deep for December. Either way, I think the store meets it’s perceived objective: to add value for Amazon customers. The store was packed for at least three reasons in my opinion. Firstly, because it was late December and virtually all popular New York stores were packed. Secondly, because it is relatively new (September 2018 opening) so folks are curious and the Amazon brand is very hip. Thirdly, the store adds value to customers as an extension to Amazon’s tried and true website.

For those of you who are unfamiliar with the concept, let me explain it a little. Amazon has taken select products from it’s US website that have four star and above (five star maximum) aggregate ratings along with new and trending items and top sellers and merchandised them all in one 4,000 square foot physical location.

The store is cashless (a new trend within select retail) and is NOT set up the same as Amazon Go locations that eliminate payment lines. Customers can pay with credit card, debit or the Amazon app.

Each item is electronically signed and shows individual aggregate customer rating details along with the Amazon Prime member price and the non-member price. Electronic signage shows daily featured items.

Overall, I liked the store for it’s simplicity and use of analytics to offer assortments based on what the masses prefer. I wouldn’t say that the store was exciting or offered a unique experience to customers. In fact, I found it a little boring. Having said that, I am not Amazon’s target market for this store. I don’t buy much online, except to learn from a retail perspective. I am also a bit of a minimalist (ironic, I know) and a non conformist (look at my hair).

I also liked how the store uses physical cross merchandising, highlighting products that are traditionally bought together as in the case with the smart home section that showcases all products that work with Alexa in one section. It’s much easier to tell a category story in store than online.

I also like how Amazon highlights specific New York favorites which hints at localization. I think there is an opportunity to do more of this to better address regional variances in customer preference where they arise.

The store succeeds as it reinforces Amazon’s (and society’s) use of collective ratings and reviews to assist one in making a purchase decision. That is, many of us feel more comfortable buying something that other customers have told us is great. Great may refer to quality, functionality or performance among other things. It is important to note that rating systems and specifically Amazon’s rating system has come under scrutiny of late for it’s potential inaccuracy and lack of authenticity. See the link to the article from the Wall Street Journal that talks to this. The store succeeds by adding a physical dimension to eliminate one of the remaining barriers to online shopping: not being able to touch and feel the product. Amazon’s rating system has been used as a proxy for this part of the traditional customer purchase decision making process. When customers shop online they can not touch and feel the product so they rely on others to do so for them and verify their experience with ratings and reviews. These ratings are of course aggregated and averaged.

One can contrast the role of Amazon’s 4-Star store with the trend in retail toward customized, unique and individually marketed products. If customers demand that more products are designed uniquely for them or by them, how does Amazon’s 4-Star’s aggregation and averaging of a given countries’ consumer needs fit in? If I buy a product from this store, I can feel comfortable that millions of other Americans have bought the same item and that it met their needs exceptionally well on average. There is strength in numbers. However, if I wish to express myself and stand out from the crowd with a new shirt or if my tastes vary from the average than perhaps products from this store miss the mark to some degree. Does this mean that Amazon or at least Amazon 4-Star stores are relegated to utilitarian, functional products? More discussion is needed here in my opinion.

Being in an Amazon store, I was not surprised to see customer feedback gathered at the exit with a simple four option kiosk. Simple and effective. More retailers should use this system at least as a starting point. Funny how it included only four options as opposed to five options (stars).

If you would like to see additional pictures and details, CNBC’s analysis is a worthy read.

1 COMMENT

Comments are closed.

RELATED ARTICLES

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

RECENT articles

Canadians rethink holiday spending as budgeting, loyalty rewards and AI shape shopping habits: Mastercard

A Mastercard survey finds 91 per cent of Canadians plan to maintain or increase budgeting efforts.

Boutique Lovenote Expands Into Montréal With New Bridal Showroom

Vancouver-based Boutique Lovenote is opening a 2,793-square-foot Montréal bridal showroom in November, expanding Oremony’s Canadian retail footprint to Québec.

Vancouver Fashion Brand The Untold Chapter Explores Experiential Retail With FW’26 Collection Launch

The Untold Chapter founder Ana Rahimzadeh discusses experiential retail, fashion consumer trends and the brand’s vision for Vancouver’s evolving retail scene.

King Living opens fifth Canadian showroom in Edmonton

Australian furniture retailer King Living is expanding its Canadian footprint with an 8,700-square-foot showroom at Edmonton’s Southgate Centre.

DoorDash report finds platform helps Canadian consumers discover local businesses

A DoorDash survey found 80 per cent of Canadian consumers have used the platform to discover a new restaurant or retailer, while merchants report increased customer reach and revenue.

BUMP, Astra turn former Hudson’s Bay building hoarding into public art installation

Four Calgary artists have created a 283-foot outdoor art installation on the construction hoarding surrounding the former Hudson’s Bay building in downtown Calgary.

Calgary’s Kensington Gate Seeks Restaurant Operator for 4,874-Sq.-Ft. Dining Space

Taurus Property Group and Sable Gate are seeking an experienced restaurant operator for a 4,874-square-foot space at Calgary’s Kensington Gate, with a targeted 2028 opening.

Maple Leaf Foods Launches Canwich Campaign to Spotlight Local Canadian Food Businesses

Maple Leaf Foods' Canwich campaign brings together local food businesses in nine Canadian cities, connecting consumers with homegrown bakeries, cheesemakers and food producers.

OPA! of Greece named championship sponsor of Swim Alberta

The Alberta-based restaurant chain has partnered with Swim Alberta to support athlete development, swimming programs and the province's competitive swimming community.

Amazon launches AI shopping assistant in Canada, linking Alexa conversations with purchase history

Amazon's new Alexa for Shopping combines customer preferences, shopping history and AI-generated product insights, with price tracking and personalized buying guides.

Vancouver’s Downtown Luxury Zone Sees Store Expansions, New Openings and Closures

Downtown Vancouver's luxury retail district is changing as Brunello Cucinelli expands, Rolex renovates and Mackage prepares to relocate to Burrard Street. Several established boutiques have closed, while Oakridge Park offers a different mix of international luxury brands.

The Jilly Box introduces digital gift cards ahead of holiday shopping season

The Canadian lifestyle brand is expanding its online marketplace offerings and preparing to launch its $199 Winter Jilly Box, featuring seven products valued at more than $450.

Second Cup Café celebrates grand opening at Oakville GO Station

Transit hubs a key part of Second Cup's growth.

Birks opens second Vancouver boutique at Oakridge Park

Birks has opened a new Vancouver store at Oakridge Park, expanding its presence in the city with a retail concept focused on fine jewellery and bridal collections.

Buds Play and Learn Brings STEM-Focused Indoor Play to North York as Developers Rethink Retail Amenities: Medallion Corporation

Buds Play and Learn opens at Emery Crossing in North York, highlighting growing demand for family-focused retail, educational play spaces and community amenities in high-rise neighbourhoods.

Teen Entrepreneur Chanelle Chalazan Expands into Publishing with Chic & Charmed Magazine

Saskatoon teen entrepreneur Chanelle Chalazan has launched Chic & Charmed Magazine, expanding her jewellery business into print publishing while planning a March 2027 entrepreneurship conference.

Daily Synopsis: November 12, 2026

Canadian Tire aims to attract customers with price cuts, T&T Supermarket expanding rapidly, Zellers opens to crowds in Cambridge, and other news.

Choice Properties REIT reports net income of $888.5 million in Q3

Choice Properties said the period end occupancy was 97.8%, with Retail at 97.5%, Industrial at 98.6%, and Mixed-Use & Residential at 91.4%.

FBOMBZ Surpasses One Million Bottles Sold as Canadian RTD Cocktail Brand Expands Nationwide

Canadian beverage brand FBOMBZ has sold more than one million bottles in under a year, earning LCBO rankings and expanding into Alberta and Saskatchewan, with further national growth planned.

Atome Bakery Expands Across Canada With Ready-to-Bake French Artisan Bread and Pastries

Vancouver-based Atome Bakery has shipped more than 40,000 boxes and doubled sales annually as it expands its ready-to-bake French bread and pastry delivery business across Canada.