Foodtastic continues its push to acquire MTY Food Group

Date:

Share post:

Foodtastic Inc. a Canadian restaurant franchisor, continued its aggressive push to acquire MTY Food Group as it released on Monday “positive feedback from third parties” for its proposal to acquire all outstanding shares of MTY for $43 per share in cash. Foodtatstic said the $43 per share price represents a 32% premium to MTY’s closing share price on October 30 and a 37% premium to its 30-day volume-weighted average price.

“We’re encouraged by the feedback we’ve received from MTY’s own shareholders and analysts, which reinforces that our proposal is compelling and provides certainty for investors,” said Peter Mammas, President and CEO of Foodtastic. “We look forward to engaging further with MTY’s shareholders and urge them to contact the Board to share their views. Foodtastic and our advisors stand ready to hold discussions with the Board immediately to reach a friendly agreement that delivers a premium offer to MTY shareholders and secures the future of two Quebec-based businesses under Canadian leadership.”

Foodtastic is a leading Canadian restaurant franchisor with a portfolio of 30 diverse brands and nearly 1,200 establishments across the country. As a growing industry player, Foodtastic said it focuses on innovation, operational excellence, and the legacy of local brands to drive both national and international expansion. Iconic brands include Milestones, Dunkin’, Pita Pit, Quesada, Second Cup, Rotisseries Benny, La Belle et La Bœuf, and Freshii, among others.

MTY Food Group franchises and operates quick-service, fast casual and casual dining restaurants over 80 different banners in Canada, the US and Internationally. Based in Montreal, MTY has 6,966 locations.

The takeover bid has included public releases from both sides. Foodtastic’s public letter to MTY can be found here. The full response by MTY can be found here.

Foodtastic photo
Foodtastic photo

On Monday, Foodtastic said MTY shareholders have told Foodtastic they believe the proposal is attractive and want the MTY Board of Directors to engage constructively.

“Shareholders have also raised concerns about the appointment of five-year Board member Victor Mandel as CEO. Mr. Mandel is attempting a difficult turnaround without operating experience, whether in restaurants or in any comparable executive role. His relevant experience is primarily limited to board work, where as an MTY director he approved a strategy that resulted in a total shareholder return of approximately -37% over his tenure.1 Together, these factors have created serious doubts among shareholders that MTY can execute a strategy that delivers more value than Foodtastic’s Proposed Transaction,” said Foodtastic.

“Shareholders have highlighted other governance concerns as well, including the apparent lack of a robust CEO search process. This is especially troubling because, until his appointment, Mr. Mandel himself chaired the Compensation, Nomination and Governance Committee, which is responsible for CEO succession planning. His appointment came after MTY’s strategic review failed to produce a meaningful outcome for shareholders. The Board then said it would consider significant share repurchases, possibly increasing insider ownership, without giving outside shareholders the opportunity to evaluate Foodtastic’s premium proposal.”

Foodtastic photo
Foodtastic photo

Foodtastic said key perspectives from sell-side research published since MTY ended its strategic review include the following:

On the Attractiveness of Foodtastic’s $43 Per Share Proposal

  • “We view the $43 non-binding proposal offered by Foodtastic as a highly credible offer and one that MTY’s Board should engage on … In speaking with Foodtastic, whose largest shareholder is Oaktree …, we feel confident that Foodtastic has the capability to secure financing.” – Raymond James, November 4, 2026
  • “We continue to view a sale of the company as a sensible outcome for shareholders in light of the limited re-rating catalysts within a still challenging operating environment … We believe Foodtastic would be a logical acquirer within an otherwise limited pool of potential acquirers given the scale and complexity of MTY’s business with 80+ decentralized banners.” – RBC, November 3, 2026

On the Significant Operating Risk Associated with MTY’s Standalone Plan

  • “Outside his board position at MTY, we are not aware that [newly appointed CEO Victor] Mandel has any direct restaurant operating / franchise experience.” – Raymond James, November 4, 2026
  • “We expect sustained macro and competitive headwinds to limit near-term improvement despite ongoing efforts to strengthen the network … We believe this strategy will take time to materialize, and we remain on the sidelines pending greater visibility.” – RBC, October 12, 2026
  • “Against this backdrop, we see few catalysts for a meaningful near-term valuation re-rating … We do not see consumer spending headwinds easing in the near term.” – TD Cowen, October 13, 2026

More from Retail Insider:

Mario Toneguzzi
Mario Toneguzzi
Mario Toneguzzi, based in Calgary, has more than 40 years experience as a daily newspaper writer, columnist, and editor. He worked for 35 years at the Calgary Herald covering sports, crime, politics, health, faith, city and breaking news, and business. He is the Co-Editor-in-Chief with Retail Insider in addition to working as a freelance writer and consultant in communications and media relations/training. Mario was named as a RETHINK Retail Top Retail Expert in 2024.

MORE FROM AUTHOR

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

Related articles