Optimizing the Click-and-Collect Trend: The Challenges and Benefits

Date:

Share post:

By Joe Woods

The growing e-commerce trend of click-and-collect is upon us, especially with holiday shopping right around the corner.

The concept of click-and-collect is simple. A customer orders a product online and then proceeds directly to the physical retailer to collect his purchase. The popularity of this trend is that each shopper is able to browse online from the comfort of his own home and, rather than pay for shipping and anticipate the delivery, the shopper can collect his purchase from the store at his own convenience.

Benefits of click-and-collect are rich for both customers and retailers. For shoppers, it is a reasonable alternative to expensive same-day delivery, allowing shoppers to forgo shipping altogether and pick up locally. Shoppers have more options online than when shopping in-store. Retailers are also adopting price matching techniques with click-and-collect, giving shoppers cheaper price options as well as more product options.

For retailers who are continuously looking for ways to leverage their existing online solutions, a key way to earn consumer confidence is through a physical presence. Click-and-collect gives customers a tangible way to relate to a brand. This provides shoppers with a tactile engagement with products and also gives the assurance that they can immediately connect with customer service. Click-and-collect also allows for many retailers to focus on clearing their warehouses and store inventories, which effectively optimizes their brick and mortar shelf space for fulfillment for online customers. Eliminating seasonal rotations, store-to-store transfers and being able to use stores as customer pickups, or even shipment points, can eliminate many operational costs to an organization.

Though managing inventory is one major benefit to click-and-collect, in-store figures may often be harder to predict by allowing the service. Systems must be updated frequently to keep the most accurate figures both online and in-store. Additionally, some items may be more difficult to monitor if they are in-stock, set aside by store staff, or have been otherwise lost in storage. It is important to be transparent with the customer that his requests are subject to acknowledgement and confirmation by store staff. Difficulties can than be avoided when customer arrives at store to pick up product.

Reversely, these levels must also be visible and directly communicated with store management and sales staff as well. A key solution for this issue is to show inventory and a time check as to when the update was last made. This allows the customer some degree of confidence in the information.

Just as accurately communicating the order to the physical store is crucial, the store staff needs to be ready to respond to online orders in an effective way. This should be led by dedicated team members and be monitored with an overall process to alert the store that an online order has been made. A store must be able to trust its staff to properly keep track of inventory, monitor online purchases and set products aside in anticipation of the shopper’s arrival. This accuracy and brand engagement can be strengthened through incentive programs and should be an extreme priority. Incentives must be updated to allow for online transactions to be rewarded in a way that properly motivates staff to respond to these requests and service these customers properly.

The last essential key to implementing a successful click-and-collect feature is embracing a single customer view. Rather than separating consumers by “in store only” or “web order only”, retailers need to embrace a seamless integration between all touch points. The reality is that customers do not categorize themselves as an in-store shopper or an online shopper. They just recognize that they are buying a product from “x” store. To truly understand their needs and expectations, brands should embrace that understanding as well.

Though there are many challenges in implementing a successful click-and-collect service, brands that embrace these obstacles will likely satisfy customer needs, making for loyal shoppers. Realistically, a successful implementation does not happen overnight. Click-and-collect features should be heavily tested for glitches and clarity before brands offer the service to shoppers. A strong technology partner will be essential to help the brand achieve its goal.

Joe Woods, president of Loop Integration, is an experienced omni-commerce consultant and solution architect with more than 14 years of experience implementing retail commerce solutions.  His background includes time as a technical consultant for Technology Solutions Company, before joining Blue Martini Software in 2000.  Woods is a co-founder of contiigo (formerly Loyalty Tech) in Sydney and has built a successful team culminating in the hybris APAC partner of the year award in 2012.

RELATED ARTICLES

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

RECENT articles

UNIQLO to Open Flagship at Vancouver’s CF Pacific Centre

UNIQLO's planned CF Pacific Centre flagship will open in spring 2027, adding a roughly 37,000-square-foot downtown Vancouver store to its six existing Metro Vancouver locations. The store joins Aritzia and Simons in Cadillac Fairview's redevelopment of the former Nordstrom premises.

Statistics Canada: Canada’s retail workforce is aging as AI adoption grows

Statistics Canada reports an aging retail workforce, rising AI adoption and uneven employment growth as Canadian retailers adapt to e-commerce and changing consumer spending.

Retail Insider “Q3 2026 Luxury Report”: Flagship Investment Changes the Store Economics

Luxury investment focused on selected Canadian properties, service and customer relationships in Q3. Retail Insider’s report examines the operating choices behind flagships, brand boutiques and more selective expansion.

adidas Canada partners with Montreal Canadiens, Cole Caufield

It gives adidas branding at the Bell Centre and feature the Canadiens winger in upcoming Canadian marketing campaigns.

The Shops at Buffalo Run Retail Centre Near Calgary Listed for Sale

The Shops at Buffalo Run near Calgary is for sale, offering 279,756 square feet of retail space, 93.7% occupancy and nearby Costco and Real Canadian Superstore anchors.

Intimissimi and Calzedonia Open First Canadian Stores at CF Sherway Gardens

Italian fashion brands Intimissimi and Calzedonia have opened their first Canadian stores at CF Sherway Gardens in Toronto. ILT Group is planning a broader Canadian expansion, with another Intimissimi location scheduled for spring 2027.

Sweat and Tonic to open third Toronto location in Yorkville

The 18,000-square-foot fitness and wellness facility will offer about 300 weekly classes, a group strength training studio and recovery amenities.

Ottawa introduces two-for-one rule to reduce regulatory burden on businesses

The federal government’s new directive will require regulators to assess competitiveness, remove outdated rules and review regulations regularly.

Behind Oakridge Park’s Ambitious Fashion Show: Luxury Retail, John Legend and a New Vancouver Tradition

Oakridge Park's inaugural Front Row fashion event brought together John Legend, Joe Zee, more than 40 boutiques and a 250-person production crew. QuadReal's Irene Quan explains the luxury retail strategy, customer engagement initiatives and plans to establish an annual Vancouver fashion event.

Daily Synopsis: October 23, 2026

Loblaw CEO says discount stores are key to winning, made-in-Canada embraced for Halloween, FIFA store remains open in Vancouver, numbers show resilience, and other news.

From The Desk: Social Media Growth, Store Modernization and AI’s Impact on Retail Marketing

Canadian retailers focus on digital-driven growth, store upgrades and authentic brand experiences amid rising AI-produced marketing content and property shifts.

Retail Insider’s Canadian Retail Monitor: October 2026 — Retail Spending Rebounds, but Growth Remains Uneven

Canadian retail sales rose 1.2% in August 2026 to $74.6 billion, with gains across all nine major subsectors. Retail Insider's October Canadian Retail Monitor examines category performance, regional differences, wholesale activity, e-commerce growth and persistent affordability pressures heading into the holiday season.

RETHINK Retail Expands Executive Communities Under Canadian Leadership

RETHINK Retail is expanding its executive communities under Canadian CEO Marie Chevrier Schwartz, with Chris Parsons appointed VP of Audience. The company is developing Canadian programming focused on AI, retail media and industry collaboration.

Retail sales climb to nearly $75 billion in August: Statistics Canada

Core retail sales, which exclude gasoline stations and fuel vendors and motor vehicle and parts dealers, were up 1.1% in August.

Retail Insider “Q3 2026 Apparel & Fashion Report”: Stores Have to Earn Their Investment

Canadian fashion retailers are expanding, relocating and closing stores within the same market. The Q3 report examines why location productivity and network contribution matter more than headline store counts.

Canadian Franchise Sector Supports Nearly 2 Million Jobs: CFA

Canadian Franchise Association CEO Sherry McNeil discusses franchise ownership, opportunities for entrepreneurs, industry growth and the importance of due diligence.

OpenTable report highlights restaurants’ economic impact on Canadian communities

OpenTable survey finds half of Canadian diners spend an average of $133 at nearby businesses before or after restaurant visits, while no-shows remain a cost for operators.

Tahini’s targets 30 new restaurants as social media drives franchise growth

The Canadian Mediterranean fusion chain has 76 restaurants and plans further expansion in Canada and the U.S., with some franchisees discovering the brand online.

Toronto-Based Panda Hub Raises $4 Million to Expand Mobile Car Care Marketplace

Panda Hub plans to launch its Panda 2.0 platform, enter new markets and add premium automotive services as it prepares for Series A funding.

Canadian Small Businesses Emphasize Local Identity as Holiday Costs Rise: VistaPrint Survey

VistaPrint research finds 51% of Canadian small businesses cite financial pressures as a key holiday challenge, while 32% prioritize attracting new customers.