Why Amazon Go is a ‘No-Go’ for Most Retailers

Date:

Share post:

Innovation is happening all around the Canadian retail industry. Retailers like London Drugs and their new LDExpress stores, La Maison Simons’ synchronizing supply chain and even small retailers like Edmonton-based Poppy Barley are getting in on the innovation act. The David Sobey Centre for Innovation in Retailing and Services and their newly launched Innovation, Strategy and Excellence program is a testament to how important innovation is to Canadian retailers Retail Innovation: Must-Attend Executive Development Program.

Beyond the great work being done in Canada, it behooves Canadian retailers to also look south of the 49th parallel for inspiration and one story that seems to be consuming much of the innovation oxygen lately is the newly opened Amazon Go store in Seattle.

As Nick Wingfield, technology correspondent for New York Times described in his vivid, first-hand account of shopping at the Amazon Go store Inside Amazon Go, a Store of the Future, it’s hard not to get excited about the future of retailing.

And while the retail industry can use all the good press it can get, I’m not sure this is it.

It was a strange juxtaposition to see giddy customers line up for hours for the privilege to ‘grab and dash’ a box of granola bars and a vanilla soda only to avoid a check-out line in the store – an ironic twist that was amusingly lampooned on a recent episode of The Daily Show with Trevor Noah.

As much as check-out lines are the bane of retailing – a legitimate friction point that causes some shoppers to switch from bricks to clicks and buy online – cashier-less checkout is not a panacea for the challenges brick-and-mortar retailers are facing.

Image: Amazon Go

Cashiers aren’t the problem – a lack of cashiers is

While some retailers are quick to blame diminishing mall traffic or confounding Millennials’ and their erratic buying behavior for their same-store sales woes, they need look no further than their own stores. It’s obnoxious to make customers wait an inordinate amount of time to hand-over their hard-earned money, but that’s exactly what happens in retail stores every hour of every day.

The ‘check-out problem’ so many retailers seem to have is largely self-inflicted. Retailers, it seems, are genetically conditioned to cut expenses, and as every retailer knows, store labor (including cashiers) is the largest expense. It is utterly blasphemous for a well-intentioned store manager to ask for additional labor hours, even when she witnesses disgruntled shoppers storming out of the store in disgust, leaving abandoned shopping carts in their wake.

Part of the problem is that many retail executives today believe that they can algorithm their way to success – if AI and Machine Learning can help cure cancer then surely it can solve the comparatively trivial issue of improving the shopper experience in retail stores. But it’s as close to reality as humans living on Mars – with all due respect to Elon Musk – it’s theoretically possible, but mind-bogglingly impractical.

Image: Amazon Go

Sensors versus people

The 1,800-square foot Amazon Go store is chock full of hundreds of sensors, cameras and scanners, according to Devin Coldewey a writer for TechCrunch Inside Amazon’s surveillance-powered, no check-out convenience store. While the details of exactly how all this technology works and what it cost was not disclosed, it’s hard to image that it was nothing short of a small fortune. And, the ongoing expense of maintaining this super-computer disguised as a convenience store would likely consume a substantial portion of a sizable retail chain’s entire annual IT budget.

While the technology overhead alone would exclude virtually every brick-and-mortar retailer from an Amazon Go-esque deployment at scale, there’s another issue that would be troubling to most retailers – theft. According to TechCrunch’s Coldewey, “a certain amount of ‘lossage’ is anticipated [by Amazon]…and if you manage to get out without paying for something, the company doesn’t officially care.” Well most retailers do care about theft and the impact it has on their bottom line. Bill Turner of Loss Prevention Magazine raises some interesting questions in, Now Amazon Doesn’t Care If You “Accidentally” Shoplift.

There’s no doubt that the ‘cool-factor’ and publicity Amazon receives makes the return on investment more than acceptable. However, when you consider that a typical 1,800-square foot convenience store might have two cashiers being paid $12 per hour (if they’re lucky), it would be impossible for even the largest, most successful retailers to make a rational financial case for this – at least not using the current technology available.

Frankly, I doubt that Amazon will expand their Go concept any time soon or very far. Furthermore, I’d bet my RRSP that there’s close to a zero-percent chance that they will roll-out the ‘Go-platform’ to their 474 Whole Foods stores, which average 39,000-square feet in size. Simple math says these stores would require five or six thousand sensors – each. Even the mighty Amazon, awash in cash from their wildly successful web services business, would have a hard time making the numbers make sense.

Image: Amazon Go

Retailers High Jump and Amazon Pole Vaults

Amazon’s relentless pursuit of innovation is truly impressive and even inspiring, but they are playing an entirely different game than most every other retailer. Brick-and-mortar retailers that try to chase Amazon are destined to fail – they can’t possibly sustain the retail moon-shots Amazon seems to make every other quarter.

And yet, the retail industry is undergoing cataclysmic change. Business results are challenged and stores are being shuttered. Traditional approaches and strategies that have worked reliably in the past do not today. As one retail executive confided, “nothing seems to be working…we’re questioning everything.”

The allure of technology as the panacea for all that ails brick-and-mortar retailing, like the type epitomized by Amazon Go, is compelling. But technology is hardly a panacea. And for some retailers, too many misplaced technology bets could exacerbate an already precarious financial situation and waste precious time as the next earnings call approaches.

My advice to retailers is to simply install a single sensor at the entrance of their stores so they can know exactly how many shoppers are visiting and when. Then, they should hire enough store staff to serve the shoppers in a way that delights them and causes them to happily make a purchase and return again and again in the future.

Retailers – Canadian and American – don’t need Amazon Go to be successful or innovative. Frankly, it’s a no-go for most of them anyway, maybe even Amazon too.

Mark Ryski

Mark Ryski is author of Conversion: The Last Great Retail Metric and When Retail Customers Count and CEO and founder of HeadCount Corporation (www.headcount.com). Follow him on Twitter at @markryski.

1 COMMENT

  1. Amazon revolutionized the internet with Amazon Web Services. They know how to do things at scale and rapidly iterate. You make many assumptions that feels like an attempt to be a cheerleader for an existing industry. Retailers ignore Amazon Go technology at their peril.

Comments are closed.

RELATED ARTICLES

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

RECENT articles

Canada Gold launches national advertising campaign featuring Elvis Stojko (Video)

Canada Gold is launching a national television, digital and social media campaign featuring Olympic medallist Elvis Stojko as the retailer seeks to build brand awareness across Canada.

Good Protein secures $128M investment to fund Canadian growth and international expansion

Montreal-based protein shake company will use new investment to expand its Canadian retail presence, develop products and pursue growth in international markets.

Purebread Targets 50 New Locations in Five Years as It Expands Canadian Bakery-Café Business

Purebread CEO Christian Bullock outlines plans to open 50 new locations over five years, expand nationally through franchising and acquire Caffè Artigiano.

Reformation to Open First Alberta Store at Calgary’s CF Chinook Centre in 2027

Reformation plans its first Alberta store at CF Chinook Centre in Calgary for February 2027, following a 2023 Holt Renfrew pop-up and recent openings in Toronto and Vancouver.

Leon’s Delays Ontario Distribution Test Until 2027 as Commercial Appliance Inventory Grows

Leon's Furniture has postponed its Ontario centralized-distribution test until 2027 as commercial appliance inventory absorbs warehouse capacity. The retailer is also managing international freight delays and has completed transactions involving its current and former Edmonton distribution properties.

Adult Collectors Reshape Canada’s Toy Market as Retailers Adapt to New Demand

Adult collectors, trading cards and licensed merchandise are changing Canada's toy industry. Canadian Toy Association representative Andrew Wagar discusses growing demand, while retailers including Pop Mart, Miniso, Mastermind Toys and Toys“R”Us adapt their physical-store strategies.

Chocolat de Kat Opens Summerhill Flagship as Toronto Chocolate Brand Expands

Toronto chocolatier Chocolat de Kat has opened a Summerhill flagship at The James, 8 Price Street, Unit 6. Founder Kata Ambrus discusses expanded production capacity, corporate gifting, new products and the company's selective approach to further retail growth.

Restaurant industry continues to face stiff challenges: Actual

A new Actual report finds 67% of Canadian tipped workers have seen their tips decline, as restaurant profitability pressures lead to fewer shifts and growing retention challenges.

Retail sales surpass $75 billion in September: Statistics Canada

The largest increase in retail sales in September was observed at gasoline stations and fuel vendors (+6.9%), up for a second month in a row, said Statistics Canada.

Sunday Funday Launches Sparkling Apple Mimosa in Ontario

Canadian beverage brand Sunday Funday has introduced a Sparkling Apple Mimosa made with real apple juice, 4% alcohol, 90 calories and one gram of sugar per can.

Holiday Shopping Security: How Retailers Can Prevent Theft and Manage Crowds

Guidepost Solutions' Cathal Walsh outlines how retailers can improve holiday shopping security, manage Black Friday crowds, prevent theft and protect shoppers and staff.

Fall Fatigue Affects Canadian Consumer Spending: Sleep Country

Sleep Country research finds 52% of Canadians need more sleep in fall and winter, influencing takeout spending, fitness habits and retail purchasing decisions.

AI Sovereignty in Canada: Who Will Benefit From the Economic Value of Artificial Intelligence?

Sonali Sharma examines Canada's AI sovereignty gap, the risks of foreign technology dependence and why workers and businesses must share in AI-driven economic growth.

Daily Synopsis: November 19, 2026

Loblaw warns fuel prices could impact groceries, Children's Place filing and Canadian consumers, Toys R Us and Staples partnership begins, Food Basics opens urban format store in Toronto, and other news.

Casavogue Black Friday Event Offers Savings of Up to 60% on Premium Home Furnishings

Casavogue's Black Friday event runs through November 30 in Montréal, with savings of up to 60% on selected home furnishings. Featured offers include the Oasium sectional, Brandon dining table and Solea bed.

This Holiday Season, Fendi’s Signature Style Comes Home at Maison Territo

Fendi Casa brings the Italian fashion house's distinctive design language into Montréal homes through Maison Territo. From throws, cushions and trays to statement furniture, the collection offers holiday gifting ideas and a broader exploration of luxury interiors at Royalmount.

Who Brings New Fashion Brands to Canada? Inside the Business of Retail Discovery

Canadian retailers including Simons, The Latest Scoop and HANK. are taking different approaches to introducing unfamiliar fashion brands. Their strategies reveal the wholesale economics, inventory risks and distribution challenges facing suppliers as traditional department stores disappear and proprietary-brand chains expand.

RUDSAK expands Toronto and New York retail presence with new boutique openings

Montréal-based luxury outerwear brand RUDSAK has opened a flagship boutique on Toronto’s Bloor Street and is preparing to open another location at American Dream in New Jersey.

Cozy Earth Founder Tyler Howells on Building a Global Bedding Brand and Expanding Into Loungewear and Canada

Tyler Howells started Cozy Earth back in 2011 after growing up dreaming about making the world's softest sheets...

Canadian Watch Marketplace Dialist Takes Aim at Luxury Resale Market

Mississauga-based Dialist is entering the North American luxury watch resale market with a platform combining dealer listings, authentication, transaction protections and servicing. The Canadian startup is targeting buyers and independent dealers across Canada and the U.S.