Saving the Neighbourhood Shopping Centre: Part II

Date:

Share post:

By Colin Hefferon

In an earlier article that appeared in Retail Insider I proposed that owners of neighbourhood shopping malls should consider adding multi storey rental residential to their mix of tenants.

I suggested that they could use a conventional commercial lease structure but substitute a qualified rental residential operator for the qualified commercial or retail tenant.

I further indicated that this would have a number of positive business advantages with few if any of the negatives that residential condo development can entail.

Using this model to develop rental residential, the mall owner would not have to sell or subdivide any of its land; nor would it have to take on partners. Both of which can be anathema to a mall owner.

The owner would gain a secure long term, rent-paying anchor tenant and both the mall owner and the retail tenants would profit from the increased foot traffic.

Financing the new development would be relatively straightforward since institutional lenders are familiar with the shopping centre leasing model.

RENDERING OF BONNIE DOON MIXED-USE PROPERTY IN EDMONTON. RENDERING: BONNIE DOON

But while financing using this model would be simpler, it would not, in this COVID-19 era, be a slam-dunk. After watching prize clients lose 30% or more of their value virtually overnight as a result of the global lockdown, lenders are understandably skittish these days.

To get a favourable response from a lender, the lease will have to be structured in a way that provides a bulletproof covenant, or at least one that is much stronger than before.

When major retailers are demanding rent abatement and even rent forgiveness and long established public corporations are looking for government loans and guarantees and household retail names are seeking protection in bankruptcy laws, much more than a slickly-packaged business plan will be required before a conventional lender will advance money even for a development as revenue-certain as rental residential in a major urban centre.

What a prudent lender will require is evidence that a collaborative business relationship between the mall owner and the municipality exists. This collaboration could take several different forms. Here are two:

  1. Option One would involve the Cityโ€™s giving its public blessing to the project by, for example, forgiving payment of the development charges (for more than the current five years for affordable rental projects) and fast tracking the development application in return for a number of the new rental residential suites being suitably-sized for families with children and a portion of the units being made available to qualified renters as โ€œaffordableโ€ (which in the Greater Toronto Area usually means 80% of local market rent).

  2. Option Two would be a true partnership. As a condition of development approval, the municipality would receive an equity position in the new rental residential project. This position could be structured so as to limit the municipalityโ€™s liability while still lending its credibility to the project. In most cases this, along with a qualified head lessee for the new rental residential portion, could be sufficient for the required covenant.

Worldwide, the equity partnership strategy has been gaining traction in the past few years.

RENDERING OF THE OAKRIDGE CENTRE MIXED-USE PROPERTY IN VANCOUVER. RENDERING:OAKRIDGE CENTRE

It has been successfully adopted by a number of African countries in dealing with Canadian mining companies, and by some Asian (and European) countries in dealing with major foreign investment of any kind. Within Canada itself, First Nations currently demand an equity position in dealing with the oil and gas industry.

Going forward in the COVID era, it is highly likely the equity partnership model will become even more widely (and creatively) used.

A headline in the May 21, 2020 edition of the Financial Post (โ€œFeds to seek equity or cash from firms applying for bridge loansโ€) suggests that the federal government is aware that institutional lenders will now want to see tangible evidence of on-going public sector involvement in major projects before they will commit money to them.

While the financing requirements for major projects have already tightened, the growing demand for reasonably priced, conveniently located, rental residential housing in urban areas is not likely to wane anytime soon.

The fiscal emergency now facing cities across Canada means that the widely trumpeted plans to make selected city-owned lands available for a few hundred of the tens of thousands of sorely needed new rental residential suites have been shelved, likely for the foreseeable future.

This has created a singular opportunity for savvy owners of neighbourhood shopping malls to add revenue-producing anchor tenants while satisfying an urgent human need.


Colin Hefferon

Colin Hefferon is a planning and development consultant. A former Ontario Municipal Board (now LPAT) Member, Colin can be reached at chefferon88@gmail.com

RELATED ARTICLES

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Subscribe

* indicates required

RECENT articles

Canada Gold launches national advertising campaign featuring Elvis Stojko (Video)

Canada Gold is launching a national television, digital and social media campaign featuring Olympic medallist Elvis Stojko as the retailer seeks to build brand awareness across Canada.

Good Protein secures $128M investment to fund Canadian growth and international expansion

Montreal-based protein shake company will use new investment to expand its Canadian retail presence, develop products and pursue growth in international markets.

Purebread Targets 50 New Locations in Five Years as It Expands Canadian Bakery-Cafรฉ Business

Purebread CEO Christian Bullock outlines plans to open 50 new locations over five years, expand nationally through franchising and acquire Caffรจ Artigiano.

Reformation to Open First Alberta Store at Calgary’s CF Chinook Centre in 2027

Reformation plans its first Alberta store at CF Chinook Centre in Calgary for February 2027, following a 2023 Holt Renfrew pop-up and recent openings in Toronto and Vancouver.

Leon’s Delays Ontario Distribution Test Until 2027 as Commercial Appliance Inventory Grows

Leon's Furniture has postponed its Ontario centralized-distribution test until 2027 as commercial appliance inventory absorbs warehouse capacity. The retailer is also managing international freight delays and has completed transactions involving its current and former Edmonton distribution properties.

Adult Collectors Reshape Canada’s Toy Market as Retailers Adapt to New Demand

Adult collectors, trading cards and licensed merchandise are changing Canada's toy industry. Canadian Toy Association representative Andrew Wagar discusses growing demand, while retailers including Pop Mart, Miniso, Mastermind Toys and Toysโ€œRโ€Us adapt their physical-store strategies.

Chocolat de Kat Opens Summerhill Flagship as Toronto Chocolate Brand Expands

Toronto chocolatier Chocolat de Kat has opened a Summerhill flagship at The James, 8 Price Street, Unit 6. Founder Kata Ambrus discusses expanded production capacity, corporate gifting, new products and the company's selective approach to further retail growth.

Restaurant industry continues to face stiff challenges: Actual

A new Actual report finds 67% of Canadian tipped workers have seen their tips decline, as restaurant profitability pressures lead to fewer shifts and growing retention challenges.

Retail sales surpass $75 billion in September: Statistics Canada

The largest increase in retail sales in September was observed at gasoline stations and fuel vendors (+6.9%), up for a second month in a row, said Statistics Canada.

Sunday Funday Launches Sparkling Apple Mimosa in Ontario

Canadian beverage brand Sunday Funday has introduced a Sparkling Apple Mimosa made with real apple juice, 4% alcohol, 90 calories and one gram of sugar per can.

Holiday Shopping Security: How Retailers Can Prevent Theft and Manage Crowds

Guidepost Solutions' Cathal Walsh outlines how retailers can improve holiday shopping security, manage Black Friday crowds, prevent theft and protect shoppers and staff.

Fall Fatigue Affects Canadian Consumer Spending: Sleep Country

Sleep Country research finds 52% of Canadians need more sleep in fall and winter, influencing takeout spending, fitness habits and retail purchasing decisions.

AI Sovereignty in Canada: Who Will Benefit From the Economic Value of Artificial Intelligence?

Sonali Sharma examines Canada's AI sovereignty gap, the risks of foreign technology dependence and why workers and businesses must share in AI-driven economic growth.

Daily Synopsis: November 19, 2026

Loblaw warns fuel prices could impact groceries, Children's Place filing and Canadian consumers, Toys R Us and Staples partnership begins, Food Basics opens urban format store in Toronto, and other news.

Casavogue Black Friday Event Offers Savings of Up to 60% on Premium Home Furnishings

Casavogue's Black Friday event runs through November 30 in Montrรฉal, with savings of up to 60% on selected home furnishings. Featured offers include the Oasium sectional, Brandon dining table and Solea bed.

This Holiday Season, Fendi’s Signature Style Comes Home at Maison Territo

Fendi Casa brings the Italian fashion house's distinctive design language into Montrรฉal homes through Maison Territo. From throws, cushions and trays to statement furniture, the collection offers holiday gifting ideas and a broader exploration of luxury interiors at Royalmount.

Who Brings New Fashion Brands to Canada? Inside the Business of Retail Discovery

Canadian retailers including Simons, The Latest Scoop and HANK. are taking different approaches to introducing unfamiliar fashion brands. Their strategies reveal the wholesale economics, inventory risks and distribution challenges facing suppliers as traditional department stores disappear and proprietary-brand chains expand.

RUDSAK expands Toronto and New York retail presence with new boutique openings

Montrรฉal-based luxury outerwear brand RUDSAK has opened a flagship boutique on Torontoโ€™s Bloor Street and is preparing to open another location at American Dream in New Jersey.

Cozy Earth Founder Tyler Howells on Building a Global Bedding Brand and Expanding Into Loungewear and Canada

Tyler Howells started Cozy Earth back in 2011 after growing up dreaming about making the world's softest sheets...

Canadian Watch Marketplace Dialist Takes Aim at Luxury Resale Market

Mississauga-based Dialist is entering the North American luxury watch resale market with a platform combining dealer listings, authentication, transaction protections and servicing. The Canadian startup is targeting buyers and independent dealers across Canada and the U.S.